Last June, the New York State Legislature and Governor Andrew Cuomo negotiated a bill that extended the state’s rent regulation and coop-conversion protection laws for another four years, until June 15, 2015.
The extender bill marked the first time in the last two decades that the rent laws, which apply to New York City and Nassau, Westchester, and Rockland counties, were not weakened when they were renewed, as happened in 1993, 1997 and 2003. That is no small accomplishment: The tenant movement, with its limited resources, fought the real-estate industry, whose leading lobbyist boasted that landlords had “emptied our piggybank” to help the Republicans reclaim control of the Senate from the Democrats in the 2010 election, to a draw.
The bill also made some pro-tenant changes to the rent-stabilization system, the first since 1983. But these were modest advances, falling far short of what is needed to restore our rent laws and stop the loss of affordable housing through various deregulation loopholes that remain intact.
The Real Rent Reform Campaign, a downstate coalition of which Met Council on Housing is a founding member, has sent a message to our allies in the Legislature: Tenants cannot afford to wait until 2015 for needed reforms to the rent laws. We are urging pro-tenant legislators to insist on enacting those reforms this year.
Clearly, such a move has to come from the Assembly, which is controlled by the Democrats and has historically been supportive of rent-protection laws. It isn’t that the Democrats are necessarily so great: Some support tenants, and some are beholden to real-estate money for their re-election campaigns, including several who give lip service to tenants. But the Senate Republicans are hopeless. They are owned by the New York City real-estate lobby.
Why Didn’t We Get Stronger Changes Last Year?
Last year, with the rent and coop laws set to expire on June 15, the Assembly passed a strong rent-reform bill sponsored by Housing Committee chair Vito Lopez (D-Brooklyn), Speaker Sheldon Silver (D-Manhattan), and numerous other members. The bill would have repealed vacancy decontrol and reregulated several hundred thousand apartments that have been lost since 1993, and included many other reforms to make the system more protective of tenants and affordability. It had no chance of passing the Senate, but the Assembly was staking out a strong pro-tenant negotiating position.
Gov. Andrew Cuomo made a vague promise to strengthen the rent laws. But during the six months of the legislative session, it proved impossible to get information from his office about which specific reforms he would support. Still, it was the first time in two decades that a New York governor had even minimally supported stronger rent laws in a sunset year. This helped the tenant cause.
Cuomo announced that he planned to include renewal and reform of the rent laws in the state budget, due April 1. This was an exciting possibility, as the governor has the power to place non-fiscal matters in the state budget and can control the language. In other words, he could have forced the Senate Republicans to swallow strengthening the rent laws. But this turned out to be a red herring, as Cuomo announced shortly before the April 1 deadline that he would not attempt to include rent regulation in the budget.
It could be that Cuomo gave away any real leverage he had by not including rent reform in the budget. In end-of-session negotiations between the “three men in a room”—Cuomo, Silver, and Senate Majority Leader Dean Skelos (R-Nassau)—Skelos realized that he had to agree to some pro-tenant changes, because a new and popular governor had taken a stand on that side of the issue. But he succeeded in limiting the reforms.
In effect, Cuomo and Silver were negotiating with the Rent Stabilization Association, which represents landlords of rent-stabilized properties, as Skelos would not agree to anything the RSA did not want. The Senate leader ruled out reforms such as repealing vacancy decontrol, making it harder for owners to raise “preferential rents,” limiting increases for major capital improvements, and extending rent stabilization to post-1973 former Mitchell-Lama and project-based Section 8 buildings. At the last minute, provisions that that would have required the state housing agency to verify individual-apartment-improvement rent increases were deleted from the bill.
The changes came down to four very mild improvements: raising the threshold for vacancy deregulation from $2,000 to $2,500 rent per month; raising the thresholds for high-income deregulation from $2,000 to $2,500 rent and from $175,000 to $200,000 annual household income; limiting collection of the 20 percent statutory vacancy bonus to once per year; and reducing the monthly increases for apartment improvements from 1/40th to 1/60th of the cost of the renovations—but only for buildings with more than 35 apartments. Tenants in smaller buildings still must pay the old increases.
Speaker Silver clearly wanted something stronger. It is unclear exactly what Cuomo wanted, as all negotiations took place behind closed doors, and the governor never publicly articulated a specific position on any of these issues.
However, Cuomo deserves credit in one important area: With strong support from Silver, he insisted that he would not allow amendments to undo important victories tenants had won in the courts, including the Roberts v. Tishman Speyer ruling issued in 2009. In past sunset years, landlords had gotten the Legislature to reverse court decisions favorable to tenants.
In Roberts, the Court of Appeals, the state’s highest, found that thousands of apartments in buildings receiving J-51 or 421-a tax benefits had been illegally deregulated, as the law clearly prohibits deregulation in those programs. As a result, some 40,000 to 60,000 apartments were put back under rent stabilization.
The 2011 bill included no provisions undercutting Roberts, nor two other important Court of Appeals rulings: Grimm v. DHCR, which required the state Division of Housing and Community Renewal to investigate a rent overcharge more than four years old where there was evidence of landlord fraud; and Cintron v. Calogero, which required DHCR to consider two rent-reduction orders issued prior to but still in effect during the four years preceding the filing of an overcharge complaint. Grimm and Cintron are important exceptions to the “four-year rule,” which generally prohibits the filing of rent overcharge complaints more than four years following the alleged overcharge.
Now What?
For several months members of the Real Rent Reform Campaign have met with our allies in the Legislature to help them develop a strategy for moving the tenant agenda in 2012. Many legislators agree with us that we cannot simply sit and wait for 2015.
Members of the Black, Puerto Rican, Hispanic and Asian Legislative Caucus were especially unhappy with the 2011 rent bill. Because it did not strengthen sections of the rent laws that particularly affect low-income tenants—issues such as MCI increases and preferential-rent increases—Caucus members felt that their districts would not benefit from the changes.
Members of the Caucus met with Cuomo two days before both houses voted on the bill to ask him to reopen negotiations with the Senate and fight for stronger tenant protections. Cuomo told the legislators that he could not do that, but that he would work with them for stronger enforcement. (See story on page 1.)
Caucus members have been pushing their colleagues to work for stronger rent laws this year. And there are signs that Silver is thinking along the same lines.
It is unusual for the Legislature to address rent issues in a non-sunset year. But a related issue gives our side some control: The J-51 tax-benefit statute expired on December 31, and real estate wants this lucrative program renewed.
J-51 is a $257 million subsidy to owners who make certain kinds of improvements to their properties in New York City, reducing their real-estate taxes by significant amounts. Many legislators want to target those benefits to truly affordable housing, and to use renewal as leverage to win stronger rent protections.
Assemblymember Hakeem Jeffries (D-Brooklyn) has been circulating a letter to the Speaker urging him not to renew J-51 in its current form. All but a few members of the Caucus have signed it, as have many other members of the Assembly.
Unlike last year, when the Senate and landlords had the leverage because the rent laws were expiring, in 2012 Speaker Silver and tenants have the leverage, because J-51 has expired. If Governor Cuomo sides with Silver, we can win much stronger reforms than we did last year.
The sunset of the J-51 statute in no way affects existing J-51 contracts, or any apartment reregulated because of Roberts. It merely means that the City of New York cannot award benefits to new projects.
The R3 Campaign is gearing up for this campaign. If we have learned anything, it is that when we mobilize the grass roots, we win. When tenants sit on their hands, we lose.
To find out how you can get involved, please get in touch with Met Council at (212) 979-0611, www.metcouncilonhousing.org