The Rent Guidelines Board’s five public members are supposed to be neutral, to balance the competing interests of landlords and tenants and produce a fair result. They’re also supposed to know enough about money, housing, and law to do that job with some expertise.
The current public members’ backgrounds, however, would seem to indicate that they know the technicalities, but not the realities, of how people in this city live and pay rent on incomes averaging $38,000 a year. Mayor Michael Bloomberg has appointed three from the world of high finance, from Wall Street and real estate. The other two come from the more technical end of government service.
The three from finance:
• David H. Wenk, appointed in 2008, is executive director of capital markets at the real-estate firm Cushman & Wakefield, a major international commercial-property broker, adviser, and manager. “Our objective is to advise clients on how to maximize the value of their real estate,” the Capital Markets Group boasts. “We assist them in extracting that value through the application of sophisticated financial strategies and funding mechanisms.”
• Courtney Moore, who joined the board in 2011, is a “private wealth adviser” and executive at Merrill Lynch’s Ryan Group, serving “high-net-worth families.” One of her specialties is helping families with second- and third-generation wealth find the lowest tax rates for transferring their assets to the next generation. “We know that asset location is as important as asset allocation,” the Ryan Group says.
• New member Tanya Levy-Odom is a vice-president and equity research analyst at the asset-management firm of AllianceBernstein. The firm handles more than $440 billion in investments in the U.S. and abroad for individuals, mutual funds, and institutions.
The other two:
• Jonathan Kimmel, appointed in 2006 and moved up to chair in 2010, is a lawyer specializing in pensions. He is the former legal director of the city Teachers’ Retirement System and was also a member of the New York City Residential Mortgage Insurance Corporation. He’s supported former chair Marvin Markus’ proposals for minimum increases on low-rent tenants and pushed for higher increases than other public members.
• New member Carol Shine has been a lawyer for the City Council’s land-use division for more than 17 years.
Since Bloomberg took office, only one public member has ever voted not to increase rents: Martin Zelnik, an architect who supported a rent freeze in 2005. The mayor fired him before the next year’s vote. More recently, Bloomberg has replaced Risa Levine and Betty Phillips Adams, public members who formed a slightly more moderate bloc.