Home-Rule Demand Grows 

When Bill deBlasio accepted the endorsement of the Tenants Political Action Committee in front of Stuyvesant Town during last year’s mayoral campaign, he pledged he would fight to regain New York City control over our rent and eviction laws in the same way outgoing mayor Michael Bloomberg had fought for mayoral control over schools.

With the state’s rent-stabilization law set to expire June 15, the issue of restoring the city’s home rule has been drawing increasing attention. That means repealing the Urstadt law, a part of Nelson Rockefeller’s 1971 vacancy-decontrol package that prevents the city from enacting rent regulations stricter than the state’s. The state legislature has repeatedly weakened tenant protections, and it tightened the restrictions on the city when it renewed the rent laws in 2003, specifically to forestall a local law reforming the Rent Guidelines Board. 

“Repeal of Urstadt,” City Councilmember Jumaane Williams (D/WFP-Brooklyn) declared at a City Hall rally Sept. 30, “would fix a broken system that has allowed upstate districts who have no rent-regulated tenants to decide the fate of our city’s renters. Once this law is repealed, we will be able to make a serious impact on the affordable-housing crisis that has plagued our city for far too long.”

Public Advocate Letitia James and Comptroller Scott Stringer have also been strong advocates of restoring home rule. It was part of the Council’s Progressive Caucus platform in last year’s election, and some Councilmembers are also looking at ways to challenge the Urstadt law’s constitutionality. The Working Families Party reaffirmed its support for home rule at its state convention in May.

“There have been efforts to repeal the Urstadt Law from the day it was passed,” said Assemblymember Dick Gottfried, who has been in the Legislature since 1970. “I think there is more momentum this year than ever before.”

The mayor’s leadership on this issue is critical. In 2009, Bloomberg told the WFP endorsement meeting that enacting stronger rent and eviction laws to address skyrocketing homelessness was “Albany’s problem,” not his. 

 

Home Rule a “Distraction”?

Not everyone is on board with the call for home rule, however. The Gotham Gazette reported on Sept. 16 that real-estate and construction interests gave more than $7.5 million to legislators in the last state campaign cycle (2011-2012). This largesse has not been wasted, as a number of Albany politicians are noncommittal on the issue, including Gov. Andrew Cuomo; Sen. Jeff Klein, leader of the breakaway-Democrat faction; and even state Senate Democratic leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins (who sponsored a bill to repeal Urstadt in 2007). The Gotham Gazette also reported that some tenant advocates consider the call for home rule “a distraction.”

But the home rule issue is not a distraction. The lack of home rule has enabled the state to carve many holes out of tenant protections, and restoring it would be the simplest—and most democratic—solution to fix that. The Mayor and City Council could repeal vacancy destabilization and reregulate hundreds of thousands of unaffordable market-rate apartments; address illegal overcharges, “preferential rents,” and the large rent increases allowed under current law for renovations; ban the excessive fees often charged on top of rents; protect tenants in units which have lost Mitchell-Lama and Section 8 coverage; redefine the Rent Guidelines Board’s makeup and mission; and expand eviction protections. 

Taking the city’s rent laws out of Albany would also take out most of the real- estate money that currently skews the legislature—and screws the public—on many other issues. It’s long overdue.

There are at least three ways New York City might regain home rule. The first is if Democrats win a majority in the state Senate in November and then join the Assembly in repealing the Urstadt law. The second was suggested in 2011 by Gov. Cuomo, who announced that he would consider using his executive power to suspend the Urstadt law if the Senate did not act on renewing rent stabilization and adding minor improvements. Third, if the city enacted a local law to strengthen rent regulations, it would almost certainly provoke a court challenge, and the city might then claim that the Urstadt law violates the state constitution. 

That claim has not been tested since 1973, when the state Court of Appeals rejected the argument that the Urstadt law violated Article IX of the state constitution, which forbids laws that only apply to one city or county, unless that locality asks for the law or its “property, affairs or government” aren’t affected by it. The court held that as vacancy decontrol was then law, rent regulations did not really affect the city’s property or affairs. The question has not been revisited since the Emergency Tenant Protection Act of 1974 restored rent regulations to decontrolled apartments.