When Bill de Blasio was elected mayor in 2013, he ran on a platform committed to addressing New York’s twin affordability and homeless crises, including calling for a rent freeze for the city’s 1 million rent-stabilized apartments. He won threefourths of the vote.
While his appointees to the city Rent Guidelines Board have frozen rents for two consecutive years, and the city has invested a substantial amount in programs to reduce evictions, homelessness has continued to rise. As of November 1, the number of homeless people in New York City was 60,252, the highest total ever recorded.
This number comes primarily from factors set in motion during the 20 years when the city was run by Rudolph Giuliani and Michael Bloomberg. Both appointed RGB members who voted to raise rents unjustifiably year after year. They ended the policy of giving homeless families a preference for Section 8 rent subsidies and public housing. They partnered with the Republicans in Albany who weakened the rent laws in 1997 and 2003, with Bloomberg spending millions of dollars to keep the GOP the majority in the state Senate.
The mayor of New York has limited ability to address the housing crisis. The state government has controlled our rent and eviction laws since 1971, and federal aid for building and operating subsidized housing has shrunk drastically. The de Blasio administration has emphasized three fronts: eviction prevention; seeking stronger rent and eviction laws in Albany, largely stymied by Gov. Andrew Cuomo and his Republican and Independent Democratic Caucus allies in the Senate; and developing new affordable housing.
Evictions Are Down
Evictions fell by 24 percent over de Blasio’s first two years in office, from 28,849 in 2013 to 21,988 in 2015.
As eviction is the major cause of homelessness, reducing the number is critical to beginning to reverse the housing crisis. The vacancies created by evictions also eliminate as many as 10,000 affordable apartments a year, as it is much easier for owners to raise the rent drastically on a vacant unit—legally or illegally.
De Blasio’s evictionprevention measures have been extensive and successful. Funding for civil legal services to provide lawyers for people facing eviction has been increased more than tenfold, from $6 million in 2013 to more than $60 million this fiscal year. The city’s Human Resources Administration has been much more generous in providing emergency rent grants and increased subsidies for tenants facing eviction—often for a fairly small amount of rent arrears when their income is interrupted. The RGB’s rent freezes for one-year renewals have also kept a number of families from being pushed over the edge of what they can afford.
The city Department of Housing Preservation and Development has actively reached out to assist tenants in buildings purchased by speculators whose business plan is to drive out rent-stabilized tenants and jack up the rents. Even though the state significantly narrowed vacancy decontrol in 2015, owners have huge incentives to displace tenants. They can raise the rent on vacant apartments by 18 to 20 percent, tack on a “longevity” increase if the previous tenant had been there for eight years or more, and add the cost of “improvements”—and those are just the legal means. Many landlords demand illegal increases, knowing that many tenants will not challenge it and that the penalties if they are caught are generally minimal.
Stronger Rent Laws?
In contrast to Giuliani and Bloomberg, de Blasio has made strengthening rent and eviction protections a key part of his campaign platform and approach to addressing homelessness and affordability. In the 2014 election, the mayor and his allies—including the Working Families Party, progressive trade unions, and Citizen Action—made a vigorous attempt to return control of the state Senate to Democrats. This effort did not succeed, in large part because Gov. Cuomo, despite sitting on millions of dollars of campaign contributions, did next to nothing to help Democratic candidates compete with Republicans well-financed by the realestate lobby.
In 2015, with the rent laws coming up for renewal in June, de Blasio went to Albany calling for them to be strengthened. He stood with new Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie when he called strengthening the rent laws his “number one priority.” As regularly happens when the laws come up for renewal, the Assembly passed a strong bill, but the Senate refused to budge.
It was clear that only Cuomo’s intervention could get the Senate to back down. But when de Blasio returned to Albany that May and publicly but respectfully called on the governor to “show leadership” on the issue, Cuomo responded by launching a relentless attack on de Blasio. When the laws expired and something had to be done, the governor allied with the Senate to preserve most of the loopholes that are causing the loss of affordable units.
“Once again it was three men in a room,” Sen Liz Kreuger (D-Manhattan) said. “And two of them were Republicans.”
De Blasio’s efforts to raise money for Democratic Senate candidates in 2014 are now the subject of several investigations. The mayor states that he followed the law, but there has been a chilling effect among his contributors this year. He kept a low profile in the 2016 legislative races.
New affordable housing—or displacement & gentrification?
The third prong of de Blasio’s housing policy is an attempt to create new affordable units. Given the lack of federal funding, the city is not in a position to create new public housing. Instead, de Blasio has relied on a misguided strategy of giving tax subsidies and zoning changes to market-rate developers and requiring them to include a modest amount of housing affordable at various income levels. This has already caused displacement and gentrification in many of the targeted neighborhoods, in anticipation of rising property values.
The mayor’s support for reviving and expanding the 421a taxsubsidy program—which costs the city $1 billion every year—is misguided. These massive tax subsidies and abatements have produced negligible results, a trickle of new affordable units that’s not enough to replace those that will be lost to gentrification
Four more years?
As the 2017 mayoral election nears, de Blasio’s political enemies—particularly in the real-estate industry and the hedge fund-fueled charter-school camp—are looking for a way to defeat him. Bradley Tusk, Bloomberg’s 2009 campaign chair, is publicly seeking a candidate to challenge de Blasio in the Democratic primary. Possible challengers have attempted to blame the mayor for the continuing housing crisis. City Comptroller Scott Stringer, in particular, has been pointed in his criticism, with the New York Times noting his “undeclared but evident interest in a campaign for mayor in 2017.”
In order to challenge de Blasio in the September 2017 primary, however, Stringer would have to give up the Comptroller’s job, risking political oblivion were he to fail. Two others who have been mentioned as possible challengers, Rep. Hakeem Jeffries of Brooklyn and Public Advocate Letitia James—who shares de Blasio’s base in the WFP—have stated they are not interested. Tusk admitted recently that he doesn’t think he can defeat de Blasio with a Republican candidate, and he doesn’t yet have a candidate who could beat him in the Democratic primary.