Can Bankrupt Tenant Be Forced to Move?

The case of Mary Veronica Santiago, a 79-year-old Lower East Side widow who filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy two years ago, could lead to an opening for landlords to evict rent-stabilized tenants.  

Santiago, who owes $23,000, has lived mainly off Social Security since her husband died, and has continued to pay her $703 a month rent. Normally, that would leave her with no assets to pay off the debt. But when her landlord learned of her bankruptcy, he offered to pay the $23,000 if she’d move out of the apartment where she’s lived for 50 years. Given the neighborhood’s gentrification, he would be able to deregulate the vacant two-bedroom apartment and raise the rent to more than $2,500.

Her case, Mary Veronica Santiago-Monteverde v. John S. Pereira, is now pending before the federal Second Circuit Court of Appeals. The trustee overseeing her bankruptcy—who receives a commission on assets he can recover—accepted the buyout, and his lawyer is arguing that her rent-stabilized lease should be treated like an asset that can be sold to pay off creditors, which would force her to move. 

Santiago’s lawyers are arguing that a rent-stabilized lease is a public-assistance benefit, like Social Security or disability payments, and should be exempt from the bankruptcy estate. If it were treated as an asset, they continue, it would undermine the intent of the rent-stabilization laws.

“This is not what bankruptcy is about,” Kathleen G. Cully, one of Santiago’s two pro bono lawyers, told the New York Times. “What’s next? Are they going to start going after food stamps?”

Both a bankruptcy court and a federal district court ruled that the lease was an asset, and Santiago was required to take the buyout. If the appeals court upholds them, it would affect anyone filing for bankruptcy who lives in a rent-stabilized apartment. In 2012-13, 11,500 individuals filed in New York City.

Assemblymember Linda B. Rosenthal (D-Manhattan) has introduced a bill that would ensure that rent-stabilized leases could not be counted as assets in bankruptcy cases. “Filing for bankruptcy won’t land you in debtor’s prison anymore, but if you’re a rent-regulated tenant, it could make you homeless, and that’s simply unfair,” Rosenthal said in a statement. “New York State provides homeowners filing for bankruptcy with an exemption, so that they will not lose their homes. The same should be true for rent-regulated tenants, whose apartments are just as much a home as is a house.”