Cuomo Crimps Corruption Commission

Governor Andrew Cuomo created an independent commission to investigate “systemic corruption” in state government—but he apparently doesn’t want it to look too closely at his own contributors.

Cuomo convened the commission, authorized by the state 1907 Moreland Act after he failed to reach a deal with the Legislature to pass campaign-finance reform legislation this year. Its three cochairs are Nassau County District Attorney Kathleen Rice, Onondaga County DA William Fitzpatrick, and former Manhattan Assistant District Attorney Milton Williams. They and the other 25 members have been deputized as investigators by Attorney General Eric Schneiderman. The next hearing is scheduled for Oct. 29 in New York City, and the commission is supposed to issue a report by Dec. 1. 

The commission held its first hearing in New York City Sept. 17. Met Council representatives testified at the hearing in Albany Sept. 24, detailing the corrupting influence of real-estate campaign contributions to elected officials. Fitzpatrick said the commission had relied heavily on “Tax Breaks for Millionaires,” a report released by Met Council in June that demonstrated how Albany lawmakers had enacted legislation that singled out five luxury buildings for tax breaks from the 421-a program after their developers gave more than $1.5 million in campaign contributions. All five developers received subpoenas.

Many housing advocates and good-government groups demanded that the commission go further and investigate the Real Estate Board of New York’s contributions and their influence. State Senator Liz Krueger joined a rally outside REBNY’s offices, calling for a deeper probe instead of treating the 421-a scandal as an isolated incident. The real-estate lobby has been a major opponent of pro-tenant legislation in Albany—such as strengthening the state’s rent-regulation laws—and its campaign contributions have enabled it to play an outsized role in state politics.

But when the good-government group Common Cause released a report detailing campaign contributions from REBNY and contributions to the state Democratic party, the Moreland Commission did not send subpoenas to either one. The Daily News’ Ken Lovett reported that the commission staff had prepared subpoenas and that the co-chairs had approved them, but pressure from the governor’s office prevented them from being served. The commission did serve subpoenas to the Republican and Independence parties.

Many have since accused Cuomo of hiding from his own investigation. The state Democratic party has raised millions of dollars on his behalf, with significant amounts being spent to advance his agenda. The governor has received millions of dollars from the real-estate industry, which is by far the top donor to state politicians’ campaigns. This sector alone gives about as much in campaign contributions as the total amount donated by individuals and businesses in agriculture, food distribution, alcohol, tobacco, telecom, tourism, restaurants, hotels, entertainment, media, non-lobbying law firms, transportation, energy, and retail.

Other news outlets reported that the governor was thinking about an “exit strategy,” because the commission had spent enough time investigating contributions to his campaign to make him uncomfortable. Some suspect he will dissolve the commission, or that it might simply recommend a constitutional amendment to enact campaign-finance reform, which might not go into effect until after 2020.

Cuomo has publicly insisted that from its inception that the Moreland Commission has been fully independent and has carte blanche to investigate anyone—including him. When reporters asked if he had personally stopped the subpoenas to REBNY and the Democratic party, the governor denied it, but he was more vague about whether he had advised that the subpoenas should not be served.

Because the broader community—including Albany lawmakers—has been heavily critical of his hands-on approach with the supposedly independent commission, Cuomo may be forced to step back. If the panel has the courage to live up to its mission, it will recommend real fixes to Albany’s dysfunction that will force the governor to take action or openly admit his hypocrisy. 

With scandal after scandal involving the real-estate lobby, and the rent laws up for renewal in 2015, New York can’t afford to delay campaign-finance reform any longer.