Cuomo’s Homelessness Hypocrisy

With almost 60,000 people staying in city homeless shelters and thousands more sleeping on the streets, Mayor Bill de Blasio has been under increasing criticism in recent months over his administration’s responses to New York City’s homelessness epidemic. That criticism, however, has often come from those who, like Gov. Andrew Cuomo, have helped make the city’s housing crisis worse. 

The causes of homelessness in New York City are not difficult to pinpoint. Along with an upper crust of millionaires and billionaires, New York has more than 1.7 million people, including a quarter of its children, who live on incomes below the federal poverty line—less than $11,800 a year for an individual, and $24,250 for a family of four. About 4 million are poor or “near poor” by city standards, which count aid such as food stamps and Section 8 subsidies as income, but also consider the city’s higher housing costs. 

New York was already suffering from a severe and worsening homelessness crisis when de Blasio took office in January 2014, after 20 years under the failed and often openly hostile policies of mayors Rudolph Giuliani and Michael Bloomberg. The weakening of rent and eviction protections by the state legislature, which allowed huge rent increases when apartments are vacated by evictions or families choosing to move, have resulted in the loss of hundreds of thousands of apartments affordable to low-income families, as have drastic cuts in federal housing spending.

“The fundamental cause of homelessness is the widening housing affordability gap,” says the Coalition for the Homeless. “In New York City, that gap has widened significantly over the past decades, which have seen the loss of hundreds of thousands of units of affordable rental housing. At the same time that housing affordability has worsened, government at every level has cut back on already-inadequate housing assistance for low-income people and has reduced investments in building and preserving affordable housing. Finally, the weakening of rent regulation laws, which help keep around half of all rental apartments in New York City affordable, has accelerated the loss of low-cost housing.”

The city’s shelter population has almost doubled over the last 10 years, the group says.

 

Missed Opportunity or Quid Pro Quo?

Governor Cuomo’s failure to push for stronger rent laws has directly contributed to increased homelessness. Last spring, when the state’s rent and eviction laws came up for renewal, Met Council and many others in the Real Rent Reform campaign called on the governor and the state legislature to repair the damage done by Albany. They sought to end the deregulation of vacant apartments where owners could raise rents to $2,500 ands reregulate apartments which had previously been decontrolled; eliminate the 20 percent increase landlords can automatically charge on vacant rent-stabilized apartments; repeal the 2003 law that enabled the “preferential rent” scam, in which owners who rent an apartment for less than the supposed legal maximum can raise the rent drastically when the lease comes up for renewal; end permanent rent increases for improvements; and extend protections to rent-controlled and former Mitchell-Lama and Section 8 tenants.

The Assembly passed a bill on May 19 that included most of these reforms. But while Gov. Cuomo claimed to support most of them, he allied with the state Senate’s Republican majority—which he and the real-estate industry had combined to maintain in the 2014 election—to renew rent stabilization with only token improvements, primarily raising the vacancy-decontrol threshold to apartments where the previous regulated rent was already $2,700 or more. This did nothing to stem the continued loss of affordable housing. 

The real-estate industry rewarded Cuomo and the Senate with large contributions. The governor accepted $1.6 million from limited liability companies in 2015, with $900,000 of that coming after the weak rent-law renewal was signed, as the New York Times reported on January 16. Cuomo in January once again said he wants to close the loophole that enables LLCs—which are most prevalent in real estate—to give much larger contributions than other businesses, but that’s a promise he has made and broken several times. In his campaign for re-election in 2014, he accepted $1 million from LLCs owned by one landlord alone: Glenwood Management, the luxury developer cited in the corruption trials of both former Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver and Senate Majority Leader Dean Skelos.

Because New York City lacks home rule over its rent laws, the only agency of city government that has a direct impact on stabilized tenants is the Rent Guidelines Board, appointed by the mayor. Until last year’s rent freeze for one-year renewals the RGB imposed unwarranted increases year after year, even as tenants’ incomes stagnated or declined. In many years, especially during the Bloomberg administration, the RGB actually imposed an extra increase on low-rent apartments, which advocates dubbed the “poor tax.” That had the obvious effect of hastening the loss of apartments low-income households could afford.

Between the RGB increases and the weakening of rent protections imposed by Albany, the number of apartments affordable to low and moderate-income tenants has plummeted. According to a 2014 report by the Community Service Society, 395,000 apartments affordable to low-income New Yorkers were lost between 2002 and 2011. In 2013, a CSS study reported that the percentage of low-income renters paying at least half of their income in rent had risen from 46 percent in 1999 to 61 percent in 2011. With approximately 25,000 families evicted every year, it is not hard to understand why homelessness has spiked. 

One policy adopted during the Bloomberg years was the 2007 Advantage program, in which families were moved out of homeless shelters with a subsidy to help pay their rent. The program was fatally flawed, however, because the subsidy decreased every year until it reached zero, based on the expectation that the tenants would find well-paying jobs. Those jobs, unfortunately, did not exist. Advantage temporarily reduced the number of people in city shelters, but it was rightly criticized as a revolving door to homelessness, because a high percentage of recipients ended up back in the shelters as the subsidy petered out. In 2011, the program ended when Gov. Cuomo cut off the state’s contribution. The number of homeless shot up.

Mayor de Blasio has responded aggressively to the homeless crisis he inherited. Welfare Commissioner Steve Banks, who formerly led The Legal Aid Society, has coordinated well-funded eviction prevention programs, including rent-arrears grants and expanded legal services, which have allowed thousands of families and individuals to remain in their homes. The administration has also worked to place those already in shelters into permanently affordable housing. The mayor’s efforts to get Cuomo to “show leadership” in the effort to strengthen rent laws last spring, however, were rebuffed, as were his efforts to help Democrats gain a majority in the Senate so that body would no longer do the bidding of the real-estate industry.

In his January 13 State of the State address, Gov. Cuomo pledged to spend $20 billion over five years addressing New York’s housing crisis—but his proposed budget, announced the same day, would cost the city as much as $1 billion in the next fiscal year. It would slash the state’s contributions to the City University, and Medicaid funding for city residents, and transfer sales-tax revenues to the state. If enacted, this would hamstring the mayor’s ability to continue spending aggressively to reduce homelessness.