After almost three years of waiting for the rules to be published, the clock is about to start ticking for loft tenants to apply for coverage under the 2010 Loft Law expansion. The final deadline will most likely be early next year.
The Loft Law was enacted in 1982 to provide a way to legalize commercial buildings that had been illegally converted to residential use and protect the tenants from being priced out of their homes. It mainly applied to lower Manhattan. The 2010 expansion brings the law to the rest of the city, except for most of the designated Industrial Business Zones.
During the process of conversion—bringing the building up to code for residential occupancy—rents can only be raised when progress is made. The law gives tenants a say in the changes made, and keeps them in their lofts while the conversion is under way. When the building finally gets a residential Certificate of Occupancy, the tenants will receive rent-stabilized leases and protections. Tenants will retain the right to work in their homes.
The Loft Law is vital for preserving what little is left of the creative character of Williamsburg, Greenpoint, and DUMBO, and will be an important bulwark in Bushwick, Fort Greene, and (we hope) the South Bronx, Long Island City, and upper Manhattan. It comes in the nick of time for many tenants who have been threatened by large rent hikes over the past decade.
The basic qualifications for a loft to become legal are:
• Three separate units in the building must have been residentially occupied for 12 consecutive months during the years 2008-2009.
• Each unit must be at least 400 square feet; have its own entrance (not through someone else’s unit); must have a window on a street, court, or yard; and must not be located in a basement or cellar.
• For a tenant to receive rent-stabilization rights, they must either have lived in the space on June 21, 2010, or be able to prove the landlord’s consent to their tenancy through rent checks or correspondence.
• The building must not contain an “incompatible use,” a manufacturing purpose that is dangerous to people living there.
While the law mandates that landlords register eligible buildings they own, there has been no effort by the Department of Buildings to force them to do so. Some landlords have voluntarily registered, seeing the benefits of legalization and amnesty.
In most cases, however, the tenants apply for Loft Law coverage themselves, which does have risks. Landlords, some of whom are frightened of losing power over their buildings, sometimes respond with attempts at eviction or other forms of harassment. Some have pursued commercial or residential holdover cases against tenants on the basis of expired leases, alleged violations of leases, and real or imagined back rent. Others have filed suits in State Supreme Court as an end run around the Loft Board, or pushed for early hearing dates to speed up the process.
Though tenants usually win these cases without a long struggle, some get scared off, either by the legal costs or the stress of the situation. The landlord has a short window in which to exercise the unfair leverage they have been accustomed to. If tenants are facing action in another court, they must promptly retain a lawyer, obtain a stay, and try to get their coverage decided sooner.
Occasionally tenants do lose and get evicted, but in every case we at New York City Loft Tenants (NYCLT) have seen, it is because they did not respond quickly or vigorously enough.
Winning coverage can be a battle, but again, this is mostly due to intimidation tactics by the landlords. We are seeing tenants win if they stick with it, and many landlords start cooperating once they see compliance with the law is inevitable.
Once coverage is established, there is still the daunting procedure known as the “narrative process.” This involves a lot of wrangling over how the building should be made safe and legal, with landlords presenting a plan for conversion and code compliance, and tenants sometimes presenting alternate visions.
Ultimately, we feel that facing these challenges is worth it for loft tenants who have become attached to their homes and could never find anythin g else like them in New York City.
Gordon Woodhull is one of the founding members of NYCLT, nyclofttenants.org. The organization also offers a mailing list, individual help, a biweekly housing clinic, and educational events.