How to Deal with Bedbugs

Bedbugs, the tiny, biting pests that have been tormenting sleepers for thousands of years, have become a common scourge in New York City. Modern cities, with their high population densities, controlled indoor temperatures, and buildings with cracks, crevices, and places to hide, are an ideal environment for them. They’ve been found in stores, subways, theaters, cars, and even courtrooms.

Bedbugs are predators, not parasites, so they do not actually live on people. They are usually nocturnal, and feed every few nights if they can. They track down their human prey by following the trail of carbon dioxide that we breathe out. When they get closer, body heat guides them the rest of the way.
Bedbugs most commonly enter apartments by “hitchhiking” on suitcases, backpacks, clothing, bedding, or furniture. They can also move vertically along a line of apartments, next door, or across a hall.

Though many landlords favor treating apartments one by one, this can fail to eliminate bedbugs from a building. When an infested apartment is being treated, all adjoining apartments and even apartments across the hall should be inspected, and extermination carried out in them as necessary, The landlord should also take measures, such as caulking and sealing, to prevent bedbugs from spreading and the apartment from being reinfested.
Generally, a professional exterminator will have to be called in to get rid of all of the bedbugs and prevent a reinfestation. You will have to do a lot of work both to prepare for the extermination and to make sure that the bedbugs stay away.

Getting Help

Rule Number 1: Forget the Stigma—You Have Lots of Company!

Bedbugs don’t care whether your house is totally unkempt or as neat as a new pin: They’re only interested in the presence of human beings to feed on.
As soon as you learn that you have bedbugs, you need to advise your landlord of the problem—in writing if you don’t get an immediate response by other means (send it by certified mail, return receipt requested, and keep the receipt with a copy of your letter). Tell your neighbors about the problem and encourage them to check to see whether they also have bedbugs. You may also need to organize your building to put more pressure on the landlord.

My landlord says that I’m the one responsible for getting rid of the bedbugs in my apartment. Is that true?

No, it is not! New York City’s housing and maintenance code specifically names bedbugs on the list of insects the landlord is legally obligated to eradicate. The city Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD) lists bedbugs as a Class B violation. The landlord has 30 days to eradicate the infestation, and must also keep the affected units from getting reinfested.

If your landlord refuses to take the necessary steps, you can file a complaint with HPD (call 311) or take the owner to Housing Court in an HP action. You can also file a complaint with the state Division of Housing and Community Renewal (if you are a rent-regulated tenant), but this can be time-consuming and not very effective. In addition to calling the managing agent or speaking with the superintendent, it’s important to notify the landlord or managing agent in writing and let them know what steps you expect them to take.

Is the landlord liable for costs related to replacing property that I have to throw away because of bedbugs, or for costs related to cleaning infested clothing?

Generally, the landlord is not liable for property damages and out-of-pocket costs unless you can show that they were negligent. This could include a situation where the landlord knew that a neighboring apartment had bedbugs but failed to take appropriate steps to stop them from spreading into your apartment. If you have proof that the original infestation or an ongoing infestation is the result of the landlord’s failure to address the problem, then you might have a claim for compensation.

In the case of elderly or disabled people who are unable to move furniture around, is the landlord obligated to pay for workers to move furniture and/or other belongings to prepare for the extermination?

Landlords take the position that it is the tenant’s obligation to do this work or to pay someone to do it for them. Tenants take a risk by not doing the work themselves, since they can be held liable for failing to comply with the protocols for extermination. However, if you are physically unable to do the work and economically unable to pay someone else to do it, you should ask the landlord in writing—with an explanation—to help you, as these preparations are part of the “work” required to eliminate bedbugs.
Adult Protective Services will help some elderly tenants with preparation work; for more information, call 311. There are commercial companies that will do the preparation for a bedbug extermination, but they can be very expensive.

What if everyone living in my apartment has to move out for a few days or longer while extermination takes place? Does the landlord have to pay for relocation costs?

Most landlords won’t want to. Trying to recover relocation costs—or trying to get the landlord to relocate you while the apartment is being exterminated—will probably require a court proceeding, and there’s no guarantee that the court would grant the relief. (If you move out during the eradication, make sure that you do not bring any bedbugs with you. Make your clothing and luggage bedbug-free by laundering them and/or putting them in a hot dryer.)

Is bedbug extermination an “emergency” in which a landlord can force a tenant to give access to their apartment on short notice, or is it a “normal” issue that requires typical negotiation with tenants about access?

You must give a landlord access to your apartment to take measures to get rid of bedbugs. If you have a lease, it will in all likelihood set forth how much notice is required. Unless your lease specifically says otherwise, bedbug infestation is not an emergency that allows access without notice.
“Reasonable” notice is not defined specifically in New York. It may be interpreted as a few days. Nevertheless, you delay giving access at your own risk. Bedbugs reproduce at such a rapid rate that every day of delay means the infestation will get worse.

Can I use a bedbug infestation as a defense in a nonpayment case?

Housing Court has awarded rent abatements for bedbug infestations, but you should be prepared to document the infestation, the notice that you gave to the landlord of it, whatever steps you took to prepare the apartment for extermination, and all steps that the landlord took, if any, to get rid of the bedbugs.
Filing an HP action to force your landlord to make repairs is more effective than withholding rent. You can start a case whenever you are ready, instead of waiting for the landlord to sue you for nonpayment.

If you are a defendant in a non-payment case, you could end up on a “tenant blacklist.” New York State sells court records to “tenant screening bureaus,” and landlords often refuse to rent to people who have been to Housing Court with their previous landlords.

Can I break my lease and move from the apartment because of bedbugs?

A lease is a binding legal contract, and most leases don’t have a provision for one party to void the contract without the other party’s consent. Tenants who leave out of frustration can be held liable for the rent for the remainder of their lease term.

However, sometimes you can get your landlord to terminate your lease early. If you do this, make sure that you get everything in writing, signed by both parties. Remember the saying: “A verbal contract isn’t worth the paper it’s written on.”

In extreme cases, you may be able to argue that a bedbug infestation “constructively evicted” you from your apartment, which may hold up as a defense if your landlord sues you for unpaid rent after you leave the apartment before your lease ends. This depends upon how much the infestation interferes with your life and/or deprives you of the use of your home. If the landlord sues you, it will be up to the court to decide whether the bedbug infestation was bad enough to let you consider the lease void.

What if the extermination company the landlord hires isn’t competent, and I’m pretty sure that the methods they’re using won’t ever solve the problem?

This can be a tough call. If you refuse to let the landlord’s exterminator do the work, then you may be accused of being the problem. Generally, judges in Housing Court will say that that you need to let the landlord use the company it picks, and when the work isn’t done properly, you have to return to court and complain. The best practice is probably to document what the company is doing, show that this isn’t working, and try to compel the landlord to get a new company that will employ better methods.

What can I do if I believe that the chemicals a company is using for extermination are dangerous or toxic to me or other people or pets in my apartment?

If you have a documented medical condition and/or a doctor advises against contact with certain chemicals, you should notify the landlord immediately, before an exterminator is sent to your apartment. If you don’t, toxicity becomes a more difficult issue. If you refuse to allow an exterminator in because of a general concern about chemicals, you face the risk that the landlord may take legal action against you for failing to take the necessary steps to allow for the elimination of the bedbugs. Continuing to harbor bedbugs where the landlord claims to be making a good-faith effort to get rid of them can lead to a holdover eviction proceeding for causing a nuisance.

If there’s a bedbug infestation in a neighboring apartment, can I request that the landlord take measures to make sure that no bedbugs come into my apartment?

Yes, you can. A landlord has an obligation to keep your apartment bedbug-free. If your landlord isn’t automatically inspecting neighboring apartments and treating them if necessary, or sealing up holes and cracks that provide access for bedbugs, you should make a written request that it do so. If the landlord doesn’t comply, and you get bedbugs, then you will have a stronger claim of negligence, potentially giving you the right to compensation for out-of-pocket damages and other related damages.

Adapted from www.metcouncil.net/factsheets/bedbugs.htm