Mayor Names 4 to RGB

Mayor Bill de Blasio has named four new members to the city Rent Guidelines Board—with the chair, possibly the fifth vote needed to freeze rents, still vacant at press time.

The two new public members are Steven Flax and Cecilia Joza. Flax, a vice president of M&T Bank, has been its community development officer for 21 years, and before that was executive director of the Fifth Avenue Committee, a community-based organization in Brooklyn. Joza is housing counseling director at Mutual Housing Association of New York, a nonprofit that owns and manages more than 1,200 affordable apartments. She works with first-time homebuyers and offers foreclosure and predatory lending prevention counseling.

The mayor named Sheila Garcia, a community organizer at CASA/New Settlement in the Bronx, as a tenant representative, and reappointed Harvey Epstein, who works at the Urban Justice Center, to the other tenant slot. He appointed a new landlord representative, Sarah Williams Willard, who manages the Hudson Companies’ Riverwalk luxury complex on Roosevelt Island.

Three Bloomberg appointees remain on the board: landlord representative Magda Cruz, and two public members, Carol Shine and David Wenk. Wenk might as well be a landlord member. Their terms all expire Dec. 31.

On March 27, 200 tenants rallied outside the board’s first meeting to call for a rent freeze. They cheered fiery speeches by Epstein, City Councilmember Jumaane Williams, and Bronx tenant leader Lourdes de la Cruz from CASA/New Settlement.

 

Mortgage study 

The RGB is supposed to base its decisions on the reports its staff produces on the status of the residential real-estate market, along with measures of tenant affordability and testimony from the public. Two of those reports were presented at the March 27 meeting. The first, the 2014 Mortgage Survey Report, found that interest rates for multifamily-building mortgages rose slightly over the last year, but that lending terms remain favorable to borrowers and new loan volume doubled. For the third time in four years, vacancy and collection losses were down, meaning landlords are collecting most rents.

Using data on sales from the city Department of Finance, the study found that in 2013, 1,431 rent-stabilized buildings in the city were sold, a 26 percent increase over 2012, with a median price of $2,562,500. 

Despite attempts by real-estate lobbyists to paint a picture of “small” struggling landlords, both the number of sales and the price went up sharply for the smallest rent-stabilized buildings, those with 6-10 units. Volume was up 43 percent citywide, with an 86 percent rise in Queens, 52 percent in Manhattan, 30 percent in Brooklyn, and 26 percent in the Bronx. Median sales prices rose 51 percent in Manhattan, 22 percent in the Bronx, 20 percent in Brooklyn, and 15 percent in Queens. 

 

The discredited Price Index

A second report detailed how unreliable the Price Index of Operating Costs (PIOC) has become in measuring changes in landlords’ operation and maintenance (O&M) expenses. The Price Index does not measure what owners actually spend running buildings. Instead, it estimates their costs based on changes in the prices for a “market basket” of goods and services that landlords typically use.

The RGB does receive actual numbers on landlords’ income and expenses (I&E), from the annual filings that owners of income-producing property must make with the Department of Finance. The I&E data prove that the Price Index has overestimated operating costs by roughly one-third for the last several years.

But there is a more serious flaw with the Price Index: It is one-sided. It looks only at operating costs while ignoring the income landlords collect. Every year when the Price Index is released, there are news reports that “landlords’ operating costs went up X percent over last year”—a perennial excuse for more rent increases.

The I&E study gives a more complete picture. While landlords’ operating expenditures have gone up slightly in the last few years, their incomes have risen much faster. Consequently, their average net operating income (NOI) has increased in each of the last seven years. Last year’s I&E study found that NOI had risen 5.6 percent from 2010 to 2011, the most recent numbers available.

On average, owners of rent-stabilized properties in New York City had net operating income of 38.2 percent in 2011— meaning the average landlord spent 62 cents of every dollar of income on O&M, leaving 38 percent for debt service and profit.

James Hudson, the consultant hired by the RGB to prepare the report, testified that the only way to fix the Price Index would be to spend $200,000 on a new survey of expenditures. This would presumably make it a less inaccurate measure, but would do nothing to correct its one-sided nature. 

The Westchester and Nassau county RGBs do not use a price index—and have frozen rents several times, while the city board has never done so. Instead, they require landlords to file I&E numbers every year with the state Division of Housing and Community Renewal. This spring, they will be given I&E data for 2013.

 In contrast, the city RGB gets I&E data from the Department of Finance that are 15 months out of date. This year’s report will be based on data from 2012, not 2013. But there is no reason that the department cannot—if instructed to do so by the mayor—make more current data available.

Overall, however, the March 27 RGB meeting felt like a new day compared with the Bloomberg era. The two tenant representatives and the new public members spoke enthusiastically about having more public hearings in the outer boroughs and during evening hours—a frequent demand by tenants, as it would enable more working tenants to attend—and criticized the Price Index as unreliable. Public Advocate Letitia James sat through the entire meeting, and Councilmember Ydanis Rodriguez stayed almost to the end.

The RGB will hold a preliminary vote on Monday, May 5, and a final vote in late June.