On Sept. 12, affordable housing advocates and elected officials held a press conference on the City Hall steps to launch a new coalition to combat the “rampant threat of Airbnb and other illegal hotel operators.” Called ShareBetter, the coalition includes more than 100 community groups and elected officials. It also released a video parodying Airbnb’s ubiquitous subway, bus-stop, and Netflix ads that uses real customer reviews to highlight the darker side of the so-called sharing economy.
ShareBetter, says Bennett Baumer of Housing Conservation Coordinators and the West Side Neighborhood Alliance, is committed to expanding affordable housing and maintaining safe living conditions in our neighborhoods. It “will leverage paid media, grass-roots organizing, public education, and potential legislative action to counter massive Airbnb spending, and prevent the illegal hotel industry from continuing to violate state law and eliminate scarce affordable housing.”
“With rents rapidly rising but wages remaining stagnant, sharing a spare bedroom can help you earn a little extra money to make ends meet,” City Councilmember Mark Levine said in a statement. “In reality, it has also created a ‘sublet economy’ that’s seriously hurting tenants and bleeding units from our already scarce affordable housing stock. Make no mistake: Airbnb and other companies aren’t waging an aggressive and misleading PR campaign to help the tenant with the spare room. They’re fighting for the landlords who have turned empty apartments—previously occupied by permanent tenants—into illegal hotels. That’s where these corporations make their huge profits.”
Illegal hotels are using third-party operators like Airbnb to convert residential units into more lucrative short-term rentals. Airbnb is by far the most egregious enabler of these illegal hotels, which have plagued New York City for more than a decade. It is currently under investigation by the state Attorney General for violating the law.
According to Connotate, a data-extraction company that examined Airbnb’s Web site, nearly two-thirds (64 percent) of the 19,522 New York City listings on the site in January covered an entire apartment and were thus violating the state’s illegal-hotel law. Just 12 percent of hosts controlled 30 percent of the listings in the city, and more than 200 of the offerings came from just five hosts.
“The illegal hotel industry is a direct threat to what’s left of our city’s affordable housing by removing protections that keep apartment costs low,” says Met Council executive director Jaron Benjamin. “Their business model exploits loopholes that speed up gentrification.” Airbnb’s most popular neighborhoods, notes Jonathan Westin, head of New York Communities for Change, are Harlem, Astoria, and Bedford-Stuyvesant—all of which “have seen double-digit rent increases that are forcing out longtime residents.”
The campaign against illegal hotels began as a quality-of-life issue, as residents found themselves increasingly uncomfortable with hotel guests as neighbors, says Baumer. As the industry exploded, tenants in buildings all over the city faced unsafe conditions, displacement, and harassment. As tenants and their elected allies fought back, passing the Illegal Hotel Law in 2010, Airbnb countered by proposing state legislation to gut rent regulation.
“New York’s #1 problem is affordable housing—everyone knows it,” said Manhattan Borough President Gale A. Brewer. “But the boom in tourism to New York City, the rise of Web sites like Airbnb and Craigslist, and landlords and building owners have combined and made the affordable housing crisis worse. These owners are diverting units which could be permanent homes for New Yorkers into temporary and illegal lodging for tourists.”