The Democrats may have won a majority in the state Senate, pending recounts in at least one district. This would eliminate a major obstacle to stronger rent laws—but, as happened when Democrats won a majority in 2008, a handful of senators may jump ship and support the Republicans retaining leadership of the Legislature’s upper house.
If preliminary results around the state hold up as expected, including Cecelia Tkaczyk’s 139-vote lead in a new Schenectady-area district, candidates backed by the Democratic and Working Families parties will have won enough seats for a 33-30 majority. Republicans have controlled the Senate for 45 of the last 46 years, the major reason New York City tenants do not have the stronger rent and eviction protections we need.
The Democrats gained three seats, when Terry Gipson apparently defeated incumbent Steve Saland in Poughkeepsie, Ted O’Brien won an open GOP-held district in Rochester, and Simcha Felder ousted Republican David Storobin in Brooklyn. They also held on to an open seat in Westchester, where George Latimer outpolled landlord Bob Cohen. The county Fair Campaign Practices Committee approved Latimer’s description of Cohen as a “slumlord” because it was true. In Queens, Joseph Addabbo held off a well-funded and popular Republican.
In other districts, Republicans were re-elected despite spirited challenges, including those of Ryan Cronin against Kemp Hannon in Nassau County, Andrew Gournaris against Marty Golden in Brooklyn, and Brigit Fleming against Kenneth LaValle in Suffolk. Two pro-tenant Democratic incumbents had earlier turned back primary challenges from the right: Adriano Espaillat of upper Manhattan, who defeated an opponent backed by Mayor Michael Bloomberg, and Neil Breslin in Albany.
Democrats achieved their unexpected victory in spite of partisan redistricting, lukewarm support by Gov. Andrew Cuomo (who also endorsed Republicans, including Saland, who had voted to legalize same-sex marriage), and the GOP’s very large spending advantage, including an estimated $1 million donated by Bloomberg. Cuomo had pledged to veto redistricting lines drawn after the 2010 Census if they were gerrymandered to protect incumbents, but when the Republican Senate and the Democratic-dominated Assembly agreed to let each other draw their own lines, he went along. Nonpartisan lines would almost certainly result in a substantial Democratic majority in the Senate, since Democrats outnumber Republicans 2-1 in the state.
Even if the Democrats’ 33-30 majority holds up, however, four of those nominal Democrats are members of a so-called Independent Conference who have indicated that they may support Republicans to lead the Senate. The four are led by Jeffrey Klein of the Bronx, who was endorsed by the Republicans for re-election, has accepted large real-estate contributions, and has argued that Democrats should not support repeal of vacancy decontrol. The group also includes Diane Savino (Staten Island/Brooklyn), David Valesky (Syracuse), and David Carlucci (Rockland/Orange). Savino’s participation is particularly disappointing to many progressives, because she was formerly political-action director of SEIU Local 371, the New York City welfare workers’ union.
Simcha Felder’s loyalty is also in doubt. Felder won the South Brooklyn seat formerly held by Carl Kruger, who is currently serving a seven-year sentence in federal prison for corruption.
In 2009, the last time the Democrats had a nominal majority, Kruger was one of four Democratic senators who threatened to support the Republicans unless they were given leadership positions. The other three were Pedro Espada and Hiram Monserrate, both now headed for prison on felony corruption charges, and the Rev. Ruben Diaz of the Bronx, the only one still in office, who led the unsuccessful opposition to the state’s landmark 2011 marriage-equality law.
Who controls the Senate won’t just affect legislation for stronger rent and eviction protections. It will determine whether bills to hike the minimum wage, reform the campaign finance system, and enact a fair and balanced budget move forward, points out Karen Scharff, executive director of Citizens Action of New York and cochair of the Working Families Party. “We hope all Democratic senators will respect the voters’ choice and be part of the Democratic majority caucus,” she said in a statement.
As the Daily News reported on November 9, “a host of traditional Democratic forces that include labor unions, pro-abortion rights advocates, and government reformers are also looking to pressure the dissident Dems into returning to the fold.”
However, Gov. Cuomo has indicated that he intends to stay out of the battle.