On April 30, the Rent Guidelines Board took a preliminary step towards raising the rents of rent-stabilized tenants again. By a 5-4 margin, the board voted to propose permitting rent hikes of between 3.25 to 6.25 percent for one-year lease renewals and 5 to 9.5 percent for two years.
The five public members all voted for the range, which was proposed by RGB chair Jonathan Kimmel. The two tenant members and two landlord members voted no. Thus, the usual charade: “Both sides are unhappy, the board compromised.” In fact, the public members are all real-estate sympathizers, and the landlords are not unhappy with such a high result in a year when annual inflation was reported as just 1.1 percent.
“While the public members heard the concerns raised by the tenant community, they set a rent-increase range at a much higher level than what is reasonable for low-income rent-stabilized tenants,” said Harvey Epstein, one of the board’s two tenant representatives. Moore than half of rent-stabilized tenants earn less than $37,000 a year, according to the RGB’s research staff, and one in five of the estimated 2.5 million rent-regulated tenants live below the federal poverty level. For those tenants in particular, the potential rent hike is devastating news.
This year’s proposed range is much higher than last year’s increases, which were 2 percent for one-year leases and 4 percent for two years, the lowest since 2003. (Last year’s proposed range was 1.75 to 4 percent for one year and 3.5 to 6.25 percent for two years.)
The board will vote on the final guidelines June 20 at Cooper Union. These will be the increases allowed for rent-stabilized leases that go into effect on or after October 1.
The RGB staff produces several studies every year for the board and the public to review, most notably the Price Index of Operating Costs (called “PIOC,” pronounced “pie-ock”) and the Income and Expense (I&E) studies. These studies are supposed to give the board members objective information about owners’ costs and profits.
The RGB’s five public members are supposed to be objective, balancing the interests of landlords and tenants. But the majority of Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s appointees have ties to Wall Street or real-estate interests, and have little in common with the everyday tenant. They rely almost single-mindedly on the Price Index. Kimmel said that the ranges he proposed reflected that this year’s index showed a 5.9 percent increase in operation and maintenance costs for rent-stabilized buildings over the previous year.
There are two serious flaws in the Price Index methodology, however. First, instead of examining landlords’ actual expenditures, it examines price changes in items they typically purchase to run their buildings. If the price of a light bulb or a gallon of oil goes up, the Price Index assumes that landlords actually spend that much more. In fact, the index always overestimates what landlords spend on operations and maintenance. Second, the index is one-sided, looking only at owners’ expenses while ignoring the income they receive and the profits they make. For many years tenants have called for its elimination.
The RGB produces a much more useful study, the Income and Expense Study, but the public members disregard it. The I&E study uses actual income and expense figures filed annually with the city Department of Finance by owners of income-producing property. This year’s I&E study shows that on average, owners of rent-stabilized properties spent 62 cents of every rent dollar on operations and maintenance, leaving 38 cents for debt service and profit.
That 38 percent Net Operating Income figure is an average, meaning some landlords are doing better, some not as well. But a 38 percent NOI is a clear indication of a healthy, even robust, profitable rental real-estate industry in New York City. Does anyone seriously believe that landlords of rent-stabilized buildings are losing money?
While the methodology of measuring the profitability of rent-stabilized housing can be disputed, the record number of homeless New Yorkers is not. According a report released by the Coalition for the Homeless, entitled “The State of the Homeless,” an average of 50,135 people per night—including 21,034 children— slept in homeless shelters in January 2013. The study also showed that 78 percent of those people constituted families, and that homeless families are staying in shelters for longer. On average, a family of homeless New Yorkers that enters a shelter spends 375 days—more than a year—there before they can find a home.
The staggering number of homeless people coincides with the fact that New Yorkers are earning less money overall. According to the RGB’s Income and Affordability study, workers in New York City earned 4.5 percent less last year than they did in 2011, after adjusting for inflation. As of 2011, about half of the nearly 1 million rent-stabilized households paid more than 35 percent of their income towards rent.
The federal Department of Housing and Urban Development calls people who pay more than 30 percent “rent burdened.” Almost one-third of New York tenants, according to the 2011 federal Housing and Vacancy Survey, are “severely rent burdened.” They spend more than half their income on rent.
The city is in the midst of its most serious housing crisis since the Depression, and many have blamed Mayor Bloomberg. Years of housing policies favoring the wealthy and the steady rise in rents shows that he has been effective —if his goal was to lay the groundwork to make the city a place where only rich people can live.