To stop the proliferation of illegal hotels throughout the five boroughs, a group of elected officials, housing advocates, community activists, and concerned tenants have formed a coalition called Share Better. Members were scheduled to testify at a City Council hearing on the issue scheduled for Jan. 20, as were representatives of Airbnb.
An illegal hotel is defined as the occupancy of a Class A multiple dwelling for a period of less than 30 days. A Class A multiple dwelling is any building that was built for permanent residents, whether it be an apartment building, multifamily house, a single-room-occupancy hotel, or a luxury high-rise condo or co-op. Illegal hotels are a threat to affordable housing and pose very real safety and security concerns for tenants. Residential buildings are simply not built to accommodate transient guests safely.
Though enterprising landlords and tenants have been illegally renting out their residential units for short-term stays for many years, Web sites like Airbnb, VRBO, and others have made the problem much more widespread. They have made it easier than ever for tourists to make arrangements to stay in a residential unit, and for tenants and landlords to advertise their unit (or, in many cases, units). Though Airbnb portrays itself as an example of the “sharing economy”—its prolific subway ads show a diverse group of New Yorkers smiling as they talk about how much they love hosting visitors—a report issued by the state Attorney General’s office last October showed that the reality is far different.
The report found that only 6 percent of the hosts on Airbnb took 36 percent of the bookings it reviewed. That 6 percent brought in $168 million during the period the report covered, 37 percent of all the revenue hosts received. Though Airbnb ads suggest that hosts use the service “to help make ends meet” and just enjoy meeting new people, the report found that “approximately 200 units in New York City were booked as private short-term rentals for more than 365 nights during the year. This indicates that multiple [guests] shared the same unit on the same night, as they would in an illegal hostel…. The 10 most-rented units were booked for an average of 1,900 nights in 2013, with the top listing accepting 13 reservations on an average night.”
Though many New Yorkers do use the service legally, any change in the rental laws that would make it easier to monetize apartments could directly threaten affordable housing and intensify the city’s housing-cost crisis.