State Budget: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

The State Legislature passed all the budget bills before midnight March 31, a few minutes before the state’s new fiscal year began April 1. This action allows Governor Andrew Cuomo to take credit for delivering on-time budgets four years in a row, a feat not accomplished since the 1970s.

The budget as negotiated by the governor and the three legislative leaders—the “four men in a room”—contains some good news for tenants and housing, but also a lot of bad news. For one, it provides no state operating funds for the New York City Housing Authority.

 

Rent help for people with AIDS and homeless families

On the good side, the budget enacts—at long last—protections for tenants living with AIDS who receive rental assistance from the New York City HIV/AIDS Services Administration (HASA). It limits the amount of rent they have to pay to 30 percent of their income, the usual standard for rent-subsidy programs. HASA clients will no longer have to turn over all but about $12 a day from their disability checks, which put them at risk of eviction. 

Mayor Bill de Blasio has put money in the city budget due to be adopted in June for this purpose. He agreed to have the city pay for 71 percent of the cost, which seems to have broken the political logjam; the state will cover the rest. Cuomo had not supported the bill in the past.

A 30 percent rent-cap bill passed both houses of the legislature in 2010, but then-governor David Paterson vetoed it because Mayor Michael Bloomberg said the city could not afford it.

This is a major victory for VOCAL New York, which represents low-income people living with AIDS and ran a bang-up campaign for the last eight years to correct this injustice.

The budget also repeals language that prevented New York City from redirecting state funds to a program that helped working families living in homeless shelters pay their rent when they found apartments. Cuomo eliminated state funds for that three years ago, and Bloomberg then terminated the program. The result: a huge increase in the shelter population.

The de Blasio administration has indicated that it will move quickly to develop a new plan. Advocates hope it will avoid the fatal flaw of Bloomberg’s Advantage program, which cut off rental assistance after two years on the dubious theory that it would push people to find jobs that enabled them to pay the full rent. Not surprisingly, a large number of these families returned to the shelter system when the aid expired.

 

A complete sellout on campaign-finance reform

On the bad side, where to start? The most outrageous feature of the budget is the complete sellout by Cuomo, Senate Republican leader Dean Skelos, Senate co-leader Jeff Klein, and Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver on campaign-finance reform. 

Despite repeated promises from Cuomo, there is nothing in the final budget that will dilute the power of big money in our elections. It left intact the “LLC loophole,” in which landlords who create separate limited-liability companies for different properties they own can contribute up to $150,000 from each one. This is what allowed a big developer like Leonard Litwin of Glenwood Management to give $2 million to candidates in the last two-year election cycle—almost half of which went to Cuomo’s re-election campaign. If the LLC loophole were closed, Litwin would be limited to contributing $5,000 per year.

Nor does the budget put any limits on donations to the major political parties’ “housekeeping” accounts. These funds cannot legally be used to support or oppose candidates, but everyone in state government knows that this prohibition is ignored. When Bloomberg was mayor, he gave $1 million to the state Republican Party, which it used to support its candidates for the state Senate. The budget also does not lower the state’s limits on campaign contributions, the second highest in the nation.

Cuomo had included in his January executive budget a broad public-financing plan that would have begun covering legislative races in 2016 and statewide races in 2018. But the final budget contains only a laughable “pilot” program for this year’s race for state comptroller. Incumbent Thomas DiNapoli declined to participate.

DiNapoli advanced a bill in 2011 to establish public financing for the comptroller’s race this year, but it passed only the Assembly. “We had a specific proposal that was well thought out, and had evolved and gotten better from when I first proposed it,” he told the Albany Times Union April 3. He called the “pilot” scheme “last-minute, on the back of an envelope—if they even used the back of an envelope.”

It is well known in Albany that, for some mysterious reason, Andrew Cuomo does not like DiNapoli. It seems clear that this scheme was a trap the governor set for a political enemy, designed to put the comptroller on the spot because of his strong support for public financing, and potentially attracting a last-minute opponent for him with the prospect of state funds. If DiNapoli had accepted the deal, he would have had to return two-thirds of the funds he has already raised for his re-election. It also enables Cuomo, who is already sitting on a campaign kitty of $33 million, to run for re-election without worrying about spending limits. 

On April 1, the governor called the pilot program “the largest single advancement we have made in public finance in 30 years…. The advocates want more? So do I.” But it is now crystal clear that Andrew Cuomo truly does not want public financing of elections. At least not for himself.

 

Cuomo agrees to disband his anti-corruption commission

The pièce de resistance in Cuomo’s grand sellout was his agreement, in return for some useful but minor ethics reforms, to disband the Moreland Act anti-corruption commission he established last July with Attorney General Eric Schneiderman, to investigate the legislature and “clean up Albany.” Many legislators, including the leaders, wanted the commission to go away before it completed its half-finished investigations, and Cuomo has obliged them.

This is classic Andrew Cuomo: Promise progressive results, even threaten fellow politicians to get them, but then cop out, agree to a half-assed result, and claim victory—as he did in 2012, when he let the Senate and Assembly draw gerrymandered districts, in exchange for starting nonpartisan redistricting after the 2020 census.

 

Big tax cuts for the rich 

The budget contains huge tax cuts Cuomo pushed for the super-rich, corporations, and banks. No wonder the Alliance for Quality Education calls him “Governor One Percent.”

It also failed to include a state version of the DREAM Act, which would allow children of undocumented immigrants who were born here to get college tuition assistance. Cuomo, Klein, and Silver claimed they supported this, but they let Skelos keep it out of the budget.

The budget also has a new tax credit for renters in New York City who file state income-tax returns, but the amount of relief it provides is pathetic: Renter households with annual incomes up to $200,000 are eligible for up to $150 per year, and the average credit is projected at $52 per year. Also, people whose incomes are too low to require filing won’t be able to get the credit unless they file a return.

Very few people are aware that state tax law has included a modest renter’s credit for many years. This new initiative will probably be just as ineffective, and it sunsets in two years.

 

Raising SCRIE income threshold

Finally, the budget authorizes New York City and municipalities in the suburban counties of Nassau, Rockland, and Westchester to raise the income eligibility threshold for the Senior Citizen Rent Increase Exemption from $29,000 to $50,000. For New York City only, the state is required to reimburse the city for the increased cost, as landlords take the cost of rent exemptions directly off their real-estate taxes. Tenant groups have proposed having the state reimburse localities since the 1970s.

An analysis by the Community Service Society found that the increase would probably add 10,000 households to the 123,000 already eligible for SCRIE. While there are about 35,000 households containing people 62 or older who make  between $29,000 and $50,000, most of them are not paying 33 percent or more of their income for rent, the other eligibility trigger. 

In addition to stiffing suburban municipalities, the bill also ignores the need to raise the income threshold for the Disability Rent Increase Exemption program, which is lower than that for SCRIE. 

All these changes sunset in two years.

All in all, the budget is a big disappointment. Oh, well. At least the governor can brag that he’s delivered the budget on time again, never mind how much damage it will do to poor people, working people, and the middle class.