State Housing Agency Adopts Regulatory Amendments

On January 8, the state Division of Housing and Community Renewal announced changes to how it enforces the rent-regulation laws. The changes involved amendments to the New York City Rent Stabilization Code and the state Emergency Tenant Action Protection Act regulations, and minor amendments to the city and state rent-control regulations.

Tenant advocates have been calling for some of these changes since Eliot Spitzer was elected governor in 2006. While some of the changes clearly represent progress, the agency ignored tenant recommendations for others. And the positive changes apply only to apartments that are still in the rent-stabilization system; they are of no use to the hundreds of thousands of renters in units that have been taken out of the system through vacancy destabilization.

“The new regulations are a good first step,” says Ellen Davidson, a housing attorney with the Legal Aid Society. “After years of the agency’s rewriting the rules to favor landlords, these amendments take some common sense steps to begin to close loopholes that allow landlords to illegally overcharge tenants.”

“The amendments range from good to terrific. Tenants will get better disclosure of how the rent was calculated. On this issue, DHCR showed real leadership,” says Seth Miller of the tenant law firm Collins Dobkin & Miller, a former board member of Met Council. But on other issues, he added, “DHCR simply codified pro-tenant rulings from the courts. I’d like to see them be more proactive.” 

 

Highlights of the changes

Enforcement. The Tenant Protection Unit, established in 2011, is formally empowered “to investigate and prosecute” violations of the rent laws on its own initiative. Tenants have been asking for this change for years, which means that the unit can act without waiting for tenants to file complaints. The changes also expand the definition of harassment to include a landlord’s filing false documents or making false statements that interfere with a tenant’s right to quiet enjoyment and use and occupancy of her apartment.

Registration. Landlords will now be required to justify amended registration statements at an administrative hearing. Failure to register—the law requires annual registration of all rent-stabilized units—will now result in a complete rent freeze, including a bar on collection of major-capital-improvement rent increases and the 20 percent bonus on vacant apartments. These changes are a small step forward in strengthening the system to prevent illegal increases, which was gutted by the legislature in 1993 and 1997.

Individual Apartment Improvements. Lease riders must detail the calculation of rent increases, including those for renovating individual apartments. When a new tenant signs their lease, if they request documentation explaining how the new rent was calculated within 60 days, landlords must provide it. Failure to comply with these requirements can result in a finding of rent overcharge and other penalties. But the state still won’t investigate these often huge rent hikes on vacant apartments, a system that encourages widespread fraud by landlords, without a complaint from a tenant. These changes will be helpful mostly to tenants lucky enough to have a lawyer—and those who question their rent within 60 days.

Major Capital Improvements. Landlords will no longer be allowed to get an MCI rent increase for converting buildings from master metering of utilities to individual-apartment metering. MCI applications will be dismissed if the building has one or more immediately hazardous violations (Class C) on record when the landlord files it. But the application can be refiled within 60 days if the violation is corrected.

Deregulation. The landlord is required to give the first deregulated tenant a written certified notice stating the basis for the deregulation, a rent computation, and advising the tenant that the last legal rent can be verified with DHCR. The landlord is also required to give the first deregulated tenant a copy of the exit rent registration—if they have filed one with the agency, which is not required. This is another self-enforcing non-solution, likely useless to tenants who do not have a lawyer.

Rent overcharges. The four-year statute of limitations on looking back at the apartment’s rent history can be ignored where the tenant alleges landlord fraud, and in certain other circumstances. In every lease where the tenant is charged a preferential rent (a rent lower than the legal maximum rent), both the legal and preferential rents must be set forth. The new regulations also set out methods for establishing what the rent should be in cases where DHCR finds that the landlord has overcharged the tenant and the base date rent cannot be determined or was the result of fraud, or if the landlord hasn’t provided a full rent history from the base date. Depending on the circumstances, the rent can be rolled back to the lowest rent for a comparable unit in the building, to the complaining tenant’s first rent reduced by the applicable vacancy and longevity allowances, to the last registered rent if within the last four years, or if all else fails, to a figure computed by DHCR.

Deemed leases. Tenants who do not execute renewal leases can no longer be automatically charged a guideline rent increase except in specific circumstances. Instead, they will be treated as “holdover” tenants, and the landlord can try to evict them. This is a troubling change that was imposed on DHCR by an appellate-court decision.

Service complaints. Tenants are no longer required to first notify the landlord in writing of an alleged defective condition before filing a complaint with DHCR. If the agency issues an order finding a service decrease, the landlord may not collect future MCI and vacancy bonus increases until the service is restored. Landlords also must respond to service complaints more quickly in some situations.

Despite this modest progress, many of the sweeping pro-landlord regulations adopted in 2000 under former Governor George Pataki remain in effect.