Stuyvesant Town/Peter Cooper Village has a history wrapped in superlatives and characterized by “firsts.” The project—ersatz slum clearance—was the first housing effort in the United States with joint public-private financing. When ground was broken in 1947, it was the world’s biggest slum-clearance project. The dev elopment was backed by the world’s largest business at the time, Metropolitan Life Insurance Company. And New York City’s first fair housing laws got on the books because some of Stuy Town/PCV’s original tenants, including the late Met Council activist Franz Lehman, organized to fight the complex’s whites-only policy.
Frederick Ecker, chair of the board of Met Life, had a vision rare in private-sector executives. His plan was to transform lower eastern Manhattan’s old Gas House district into an affordable residential rental community with a bucolic design. Stuyvesant Town alone was to have 12 playgrounds, a greenway, tennis courts, and a five-acre oval garden. Met Life even did away with the Manhattan grid in its plan for the grounds and buildings. When I moved into Stuyvesant Town in the spring of 1990, I saw a plaque in honor of Ecker in the Stuyvesant Town Oval, which read in part:
“Who with the vision of experience and the energy of youth conceived and brought into being this project… that families of moderate means might live in health, comfort and dignity in park-like communities.”
The “people of modest means” that Met Life targeted as its first renters were returning World War II veterans and middle-income white-collar workers and professionals. The “park-like community” of Stuyvesant Town and Peter Cooper Village would stand for six decades as a bastion of affordable rental housing for the working class and others of modest means.
Until 1997 and 2006.
Stuy Town/PCV was partially deregulated during the disastrous vacancy decontrol of the early 1970s, and then completely reregulated when the Emergency Tenant Protection Act instituted state rent stabilization in 1974. However, since in the 1990s, every definitive vote taken on renewing the city and state’s rent laws has exacted a price. The changes added by the state Legislature in 1993, the City Council in 1994, and the Legislature again in 1997 weakened the rent laws to the point that they were on their way to planned irrelevance. The 1997 renewal did the most damage. It enshrined in law a new form of vacancy decontrol, in which protected units that hit $2,000 upon vacancy could be taken out of the rent-stabilization system and go to market rate legally.
That dilated the pupils of landlords in all five boroughs. Met Life may have led the pack. Nine years later, one-third of the units in Stuy Town/PCV were at market rate. We had lost 4,400 rent-protected units. Vacancy decontrol and the hot housing market of the mid-’00s set the stage for Met Life’s announcement in August 2006 that it planned to sell the complex.
Amid grotesque scrambling by private bidders, the Stuy Town/PCV Tenant Association saw an opportunity for us to become the owners, and to focus on preserving affordability and stability. The Association did heroic work to gather political support and financing to submit a bid to buy. It garnered support from all our elected officials, from the City Council to the U.S. Senate—save one. Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s public position was that the market should prevail, and he wished the highest bidder well.
The winning bid was a staggering $5.4 billion from Tishman Speyer, the highest ever in a real-estate sale. (The Tenant Association bid of $4.5 billion was not the lowest.) To tenants’ surprise, the whole process was over by November 2006. When aspects of Tishman Speyer’s business plan became public, they revealed that it planned to deregulate 60 percent of the rental units in six years and bring them up to market rate. That was the way the company would be able to pay the mortgage.
Tishman Speyer took over with a bang. It immediately quadrupled the number of investigative companies hired to track, watch, monitor, harass and evict tenants it suspected of subletting. The number of lease non-renewals went up so dramatically in the first few months of Tishman Speyer’s reign that our city councilmember (and neighbor), Dan Garodnick, worked with the Urban Justice Center to set up free legal clinics specifically for residents who got a dreaded “Golub notice” that their lease was not being renewed.
Tishman Speyer also began a development-wide beautification program, planting thousands of trees and shrubs. It then took down the plaque to Frederick Ecker. No more “families of modest means” welcome here!
But Tishman Speyer’s plans were thwarted by three factors.
First, it paid too much. It bought our homes as a “predatory equity” purchaser. The rent roll at the time of the sale could not support the purchase price, so Tishman Speyer needed wholesale changes in the tenancy and rents to make its monthly debt service of $16.1 million.
Second, tenants fought back. While at one point Tishman Speyer was refusing to renew 15 percent of tenants’ expiring leases, it did not find thousands of fiendish sublessors. It lost these eviction attempts more often than it won.
Market-rate tenants filed a lawsuit challenging the whole system of taking units to market rate on vacancy. They argued that all units had to remain stabilized, because Met Life had gotten a tax abatement that would not expire until 2017 from the city’s J-51 program for the renovation of rent-stabilized buildings. In October 2009, the state Court of Appeals issued the landmark Roberts decision, which made it clear to landlords that if they secured a J-51 tax break, they are bound to keep the units in their building regulated until the benefit expired. That forced Tishman Speyer to abandon its market-rate renting strategy.
Third, when the housing and finance market crashed in 2008, it caught Tishman Speyer without a Plan B. They had bought Stuy Town/PCV for $5.4 billion, and now had a property whose value sunk as low as $1.9 billion.
The combination of tenant resistance, the Roberts decision, and the tanking of the housing market proved fatal for Tishman Speyer. In December 2009, it announced the pending foreclosure of Stuyvesant Town/Peter Cooper Village.
The foreclosure is a non-linear, complicated process, part because the debt is in the billions and part because the debt is collateralized as mortgage-backed securities. The debt is graded by risk and value, and the foreclosure process has set mezzanine debt holders against senior debt holders, who have priority for getting repaid. The senior debt-holders’ special servicer, CW Capital, has become the temporary owner, because, after a summer and fall of lawsuits, it now owns the lion’s share of the mortgage debt.
CW Capital knows that the Tenant Association has been working on its own ownership plan this year, with the assistance of financial advisors Moelis + Company and legal advisors Paul Weiss. The Tenant Association plan, while still in formation, will include at its core:
Tenant choice to buy or remain as renters
Long-term affordability
Preserving Stuyvesant Town and Peter Cooper Village as a coherent community
Keeping t he open spaces safe from development
The plan’s main goal is to maintain the community as a stable place for the middle class. CW Capital has said it is interested in working with us. However, what is still to be determined are key details such as “affordable to whom?”; “long-term affordable as demonstrated by what?”; “rental or tenant-owned?”; and “if tenant-owned, co-op or condo?” And will these decisions be made by the people or entities that get to profit on Stuy Town/PCV? Or will they be made by people for whom the complex is unique as an affordable place for working folks? For regular New Yorkers who need apartments at rents that are fair for themselves and their families?
Meanwhile, much danger lurks in 2011. The rent laws expire in June. The Senate’s likely return to Republican hands jeopardizes this. Second, even if the laws are renewed, the landlord lobby is on fire to repeal the Roberts decision legislatively. As they pushed the Legislature to impose vacancy decontrol in 1997, they are almost certain to demand the repeal of Roberts as the price of renewing the rent laws from the legislators they support financially.
The preservation of Stuyvesant Town/Peter Cooper Village as a place for families of moderate means to live in health, comfort and dignity as it was conceived in the 1940s it at stake. For me, being able to live here is a gift. I want this development to be affordable to me and also to the next “me.”
The tenants here need a stable place to live. We need an affordable place to live. Do the debt-holders need to be paid 100 cents on their dollar? Do they need to make a profit on us?
Really, does anyone?