Tenant Groups Protest Cuomo’s ‘Abject Failure’ on Housing

As Gov. Andrew Cuomo delivered the first of his six State of the State addresses in Manhattan Jan. 9, housing groups including Met Council protested outside, charging that with rent regulations eroding and almost 85,000 people in homeless shelters around the state, the legacy of his policies has been “abject failure.”

“Time and again, Cuomo has made policy decisions that benefit wealthy landlords at the expense of low- and moderate-income tenants across the country—especially in New York,” said a statement by the protest’s organizers, the Real Rent Reform Coalition, the Alliance for Tenant Power, and VOCAL-NY. 

In his first term as governor, they said, New York City lost at least 35,000 rent-stabilized apartments to deregulation, and that doesn’t include the apartments landlords took out of rent regulations without reporting it to the state. When the rent laws expired in 2011 and 2015, they added, “Cuomo failed to enact any meaningful strengthening amendments, essentially ignoring tenants while siding with Senate Republicans.” Meanwhile, the number of homeless people increased by 25 percent on Long Island and 59 percent in New York City during his first six years in office.

The coalition criticized Cuomo’s record on homelessness as far back as 1992, when he chaired a city commission that blamed it on “social and behavioral” problems. Last month, they noted, he vetoed a bill that would have funded housing attorneys for low-income New Yorkers, even though eviction is a major cause of homelessness. (In his speech, he did promise to “expand indigent legal services for criminal defendants.”)

The governor devoted only two paragraphs of the 4,300-word speech to housing issues. In one, he noted that “nearly half the homes of our middle class” have not recovered the value they lost in the recession that began in 2007. In the other, he called on the Legislature to release funds for what he called “a historic $20 billion commitment to fight pervasive homelessness and the affordable housing shortage.” The money would provide 100,000 units of affordable housing across the state, and 6,000 units of supportive housing, most of them in New York City, “where the homeless crisis is most dire.”

The protest organizers said the reason for that impasse is that Cuomo and the legislature failed to pass a budget with the funding necessary to create those 6,000 units, and instead established a separate memorandum of understanding “that allows the funding to be used as leverage for other priorities,” such as the resurrection of the 421-a tax break for new housing construction.

“Governor Cuomo has become notorious for making bold announcements with soaring progressive rhetoric that turn out to be watered-down versions of the actual progressive policy,” they said. If he “wants to implement a successful, truly progressive housing policy,” they added, that would include strengthening and expanding rent stabilization; fully funding 20,000 units of supportive housing; refusing to give more tax breaks “to wealthy developers at the expense of tenants”; and “work to rid the New York State political system of campaign contributions by corporate interests, including landlord and developer communities.”