Governor Andrew Cuomo and legislative leaders in Albany have placed a constitutional amendment on the November 4 ballot that would establish a new commission to redraw legislative district lines, beginning in 2020. In typical Albany style, they are trying to convince voters that this amendment represents reform, that it would end the corrupt practice of the legislature drawing its own lines in ways that protect incumbents and give the majority parties in each house an advantage in elections.
The proposal is fatally flawed and should be opposed by every thinking voter. Cuomo and the leaders claim that it would create a redistricting process independent from the legislature. In fact, it’s the same old Albany game. The legislative leaders will determine who sits on the commission. If that were not bad enough, the commission would have to submit its proposed district lines to the legislature for approval, and if the legislature rejects them twice, the leaders could then draw the lines themselves—just as in the current system.
Editorial boards around the state have blasted the proposal and urged a “no” vote. And in response to a lawsuit by Common Cause New York, a state Supreme Court justice ordered the state Board of Elections to delete the word “independent” from the ballot language describing the proposal. The judge wrote, “The Commission cannot be described as ‘independent’ when eight out of the 10 members are the handpicked appointees of the legislative leaders and the two additional members are essentially political appointees by proxy.” The embarrassed Board of Elections announced that it would not appeal that decision.
Met Council on Housing urges all voters to reject this sham, and vote no.