Who Will Control the State Senate Next Year?

Control of the New York State Senate is up for grabs in the November 4 election. It seems likely—but by no means certain—that the Republicans will lose their hold on power and the Democrats will be running the show.

One reason is that the Democrats seem to have a real shot at picking up some seats traditionally held by Republicans. Another is the agreement by Jeff Klein and the other members of the breakaway “Independent Democratic Conference” to abandon their alliance with the Republican minority and return to the Democratic fold—sort of.

Of course, much will depend on the actual election results. If the Democrats pick up seats, it will be hard for Klein to back away from the deal. If the Republicans gain a majority, Klein will likely return to his alliance with them.

Gov. Andrew Cuomo agreed to work for a Democratic takeover of the Senate as a key component of the deal Mayor Bill de Blasio brokered with leaders of the Working Families Party to endorse him for re-election. As part of the WFP deal, major labor unions that have helped the Republicans keep control of the Senate in the recent past have now pledged to use their formidable resources to elect a Democratic majority. While it is not clear that Cuomo will actually do anything to help, such as actively campaigning for Democratic candidates, raising money for them, or (gasp!) giving them some of his overwhelming war chest, the involvement of these unions is a major step forward.

Tenants have a lot at stake. While there are a couple of Democrats left in the Senate who do not support us, most of the landlord stooges who torpedoed our legislation in 2009-2010 are gone. And Democratic leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins is the lead sponsor of the bills to repeal vacancy destabilization and to provide rent stabilization coverage to former Mitchell-Lama and Section 8 developments.

The following is a summary of important Senate races:

 

Democratic primary elections (September 9):

District 34 (Bronx/Westchester): Former City Councilmember Oliver Koppell is challenging Jeff Klein. There is no doubt that Koppell’s candidacy had a powerful effect on Klein’s agreeing to ally with the real Democrats next year. Tenants owe him our thanks, and we should support him.

District 11 (Queens): Former City Comptroller John Liu is challenging IDC member Tony Avella. Unlike Koppell, Liu has the support of the county Democratic organization and major elected officials. 

District 14 (Queens): Former Councilmember Leroy Comrie is challenging incumbent Malcolm Smith, who will be retried on corruption charges next year. Smith, an IDC member before his indictment, double-crossed tenants when he was Senate Democratic leader in 2009.

District 18 (Brooklyn): Tenant organizer Debbie Medina has mounted a primary challenge to Martin Malavé Dilan, who voted for vacancy deregulation when he was on the City Council in 1994, and has not supported pro-tenant legislation in the Senate.

District 19 (Brooklyn): Local 1199 SEIU organizer Dell Smitherman is challenging the twice-indicted John Sampson, who sold tenants out in 2010 when he was Senate Democratic leader, in return for what he thought was a genuine promise by the real-estate lobby to help the Democrats keep the majority. 

District 20 (Brooklyn): Jesse Hamilton and Rubain Dorancy are competing for the seat left vacant when Eric Adams was elected borough president. 

District 31 (Manhattan): Incumbent Adriano Espaillat, after failing to unseat Rep. Charles Rangel in the June 24 Congressional primary, is running for re-election to the Senate. Former Councilmember Robert Jackson is challenging him.

District 33 (Bronx): Conservative Councilmember Fernando Cabrera has filed petitions to challenge incumbent Gustavo Rivera, who beat landlord stooge Pedro Espada in the 2010 primary and is one of the strongest pro-tenant legislators.

Tenants Political Action Committee has endorsed Koppell, Liu, Comrie, Medina, Smitherman, Hamilton, Espaillat, and Rivera. Met Council on Housing has also endorsed Smitherman.

 

General election (November 4):

Three marginal Democrats

Three upstate Democrats elected in 2012 are Republican targets: Terry Gipson (District 41, upper Hudson Valley); Ted O’Brien (District 55, Rochester); and Cecilia Tkaczyk (District 46, a sprawling district covering parts of five counties west and south of Albany). All three are reliable votes for tenants, and their opponents will have piles of landlord money. Tenants PAC  has made re-electing these three a priority.

Tkaczyk, a housing activist who served as director of the statewide Neighborhood Preservation Coalition and treasurer of New York State Tenants & Neighbors Coalition, won the 63rd seat the Republicans added in the 2012 redistricting, defeating Assemblymember George Amedore by 18 votes. This year, she faces Amedore in a rematch. 

 

Republican seats

Democrats have a good chance of picking up three seats where the Republican incumbent is not seeking re-election. In the lower Hudson Valley’s District 40, Justin Wagner, a former Legal Services attorney who lost to Greg Ball by only 1,000 votes in 2012, is trying again. Wagner is Tenants PAC’s fourth priority.

In Long Island’s District 3, on the south shore of Suffolk County, Democrat Adrienne Esposito, a well-known environmental advocate, is running against Conservative-Republican Anthony Senft. Incumbent Lee Zeldin is challenging U.S. Rep. Timothy Bishop.

On the south shore of Nassau County, Democratic County Legislator David Denenberg and Republican Michael Venditto are vying for the District 8 seat left vacant by Charles Fuschillo’s resignation last December.

Almost all Republican incumbents are considered safe, but Democrat Adam Haber is mounting a credible challenge to Jack Martins in District 7, the northwest corner of Nassau County.