Will Landlords Escape Campaign-Finance Reform?

Campaign-finance-reform activists throw mock hundred-dollar bills from the balcony of the state Senate June 5.We are mere days away from the close of the 2013 legislative session. Will meaningful campaign-finance reform be enacted?

Governor Andrew Cuomo and Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver are pushing a package of reforms, the most important of which would establish a program of matching public funds for candidates who agree to limit their spending, similar to New York City’s. The Assembly has passed a bill containing this and other reforms.

Whether the co-leaders of the State Senate, Nassau Republican Dean Skelos and Bronx “Democrat” Jeffrey Klein, will allow a meaningful reform bill to come to the floor, remains to be seen. Klein has introduced a stringent campaign-finance-reform bill, tighter than Silver’s bill, but many observers of state government believe that he is posturing. (There is not even an Assembly companion to his bill.)

Skelos has expressed outright opposition to public financing of campaigns. It seems clear that he is trying to run out the clock and avoid any meaningful reform. The Senate Republicans are the major beneficiaries of the current loose system, where big money can give them unlimited sums to help them maintain their waning grip on power.

Under their “bipartisan” power-sharing agreement, Skelos and Klein both must agree before any bill can be brought up for a vote. When this deal was announced last December, after the G.O.P. lost its numerical majority in the Senate, Klein promised that his alliance with the Republicans would lead to progressive legislation.

Governor Cuomo gave his tacit support to this power-sharing arrangement that cheated the Democrats out of control of the chamber even though they have a numerical majority. Ironically, that might now prove to be the graveyard for his effort to take big money out of elections.

If a bill passes, the second question is whether it will close a loophole in the current laws that is essentially exclusive to real estate. Election lawyers call this “the LLC loophole.” Landlords who own multiple apartment buildings can set up a Limited Liability Company as the technical owner of each building. Each LLC can then make campaign contributions up to the limit that applies to individual contributors, $150,000 for each calendar year. Real-estate baron Leonard Litwin of Glenwood Management used this loophole to give almost $2 million to various candidates and committees in the last election cycle, 2011-2012, including $500,000 to Cuomo. (See Tenant/Inquilino, March 2013.)

Unfortunately, the Assembly bill introduced by Speaker Silver does not include language closing the LLC loophole. In past years, his campaign-finance-reform proposals would have closed the LLC loophole; it is not clear why he dropped that provision.

Because this issue is not in the Assembly bill, it is possible that it will not be part of a final negotiated bill. This would let landlords continue to flood our election system with millions of dollars every two years. Landlord cash to candidates for state office is the main reason tenants get continually clobbered in legislative fights in Albany.

As Tenant/Inquilino went to press, it was reported that Governor Cuomo planned to introduce a campaign-finance-reform bill on June 11. His bill is rumored to contain language closing the LLC loophole. If so, this will be helpful.

With an election looming next year and the state rent laws up for renewal in exactly two years (June 15, 2015), tenants and our supporters in the Legislature must make sure that any final negotiated bill closes the LLC loophole.

Of course, the final result might be a mickey-mouse, namby-pamby compromise that Cuomo and legislative leaders will try to spin as a great victory.

As Attorney General Eric Schneiderman warned fair-election activists in a March 27 conference call, “In Albany, they’re really, really good at coming up with something that looks like reform, and that they tout as reform, but really falls short.”