Will Bloomberg Infiltrate Infill Into NYCHA Before Term Ends?

This community center in East Harlem’s George Washington Houses is one of the sites NYCHA is offering to developers. The back of the building is a medical clinic.Despite strong opposition from public-housing tenants, the Bloomberg administration’s plan to have the New York City Housing Authority raise money by letting developers build luxury housing on project sites isn’t dead yet.

NYCHA has delayed its formal “request for proposals” (commonly called “RFP”) from developers. Instead, it’s using a two-step process. In August, it released a “request for expressions of interest” for its “Land Lease Initiative” on 14 parcels of land in eight Manhattan projects. The eight are the Baruch, Campos Plaza, LaGuardia, Meltzer Tower, and Smith Houses on the Lower East Side; Carver and Washington in East Harlem; and Douglass on the Upper West Side. 

Responses are due Nov. 18, and only those who reply will be eligible to submit proposals when the RFP is issued. However, an applicant “could be conditionally designated as a result of an exceptional response,” and it would then have to start “pre-development work” within 30 days.

That clause is what concerns opponents of the plan. Damaris Reyes, head of Good Old Lower East Side and a Baruch Houses resident, calls it “a loophole which could allow NYCHA to circumvent the RFP process.” Legal Aid Society housing attorney Lucy Newman says it indicates the Bloomberg administration “is trying to do something speedy” before the mayor leaves office. 

On Oct. 10, the City Council and tenant associations from the Baruch and Douglass Houses filed a lawsuit in State Supreme Court, seeking to force NYCHA to rescind its requests. The Council had authorized the suit by voice vote the day before. The suit, with briefs cowritten by Legal Aid, argues that the plan is illegal because public-housing land can’t be used for private residential development, it evades city land-use procedures, and NYCHA did not mention it in its 2013 annual plan and has failed to give project residents a “meaningful” voice in developing it.

Democratic mayoral candidate Bill De Blasio opposes the plan. “NYCHA land is not for luxury condos,” he said in a statement for Tenant/Inquilino. However, he left the door open for a modified version, adding, “Any future infill plan must include substantial amounts of affordable housing, the hiring of NYCHA residents for construction and permanent jobs, and the resources generated must be used to improve conditions for NYCHA families.”

Under the current plan, NYCHA would give developers 99-year leases to build on the 14 parcels. They are mostly parking lots and landscaped areas, but they also include a community garden at Douglass, a place for people to sit outside at Meltzer Tower, a baseball field and basketball court at Smith, and a community center and health clinic at Washington. The authority expects the land leases to bring in about $50 million a year, and it says it would use that to make overdue repairs.

The plan requires the housing built to contain at least 20 percent “permanently affordable” units. The formula it uses defines “affordable” as available to households who earn less than 60 percent of the metropolitan area’s median income—or about $50,000 for a family of four—with at least half those apartments available to people earning less than half the median. That would set “affordable” rents at up to about $1,250 a month, with the median about $1,040. 

NYCHA expects this to create about 800 affordable apartments and 3,000 luxury ones—but, as the eight projects involved contain 10,600 apartments, it claims the plan will “create or preserve” 11,400 affordable units. It says it will prefer proposals that contain more lower-rent apartments, but these “should not come at the expense of revenues to NYCHA.” 

The more than 400,000 people who occupy the city’s 179,000 public-housing apartments have an average household income of $23,000 and an average rent of $436, according to NYCHA. At a recent infill project, built on a former parking lot in the Elliott-Chelsea Houses on Ninth Avenue, Newman says, only about three or four of the apartments were available to people in that income range. 

Under Section 18 of the Housing Act of 1937, the law that established federal aid for public housing, local housing authorities cannot dispose of property without getting approval from the Department of Housing and Urban Development and without consulting with the affected residents. NYCHA has held public meetings to present the plan in the eight projects, but Newman says they weren’t enough to meet that legal standard. “Just putting up some PowerPoint pictures of what they’re going to do,” she says, doesn’t qualify as “meaningful community collaboration or consultation.”

Another issue, she adds, is whether developers’ promises, such as creating jobs for residents or building a new community center in the Washington Houses, can be enforced. The Request for Expressions of Interest says developers must “use best efforts” to have at least 15 percent of the construction phase’s payroll go to NYCHA residents, and 30 percent of permanent jobs must be “targeted” to residents.

Ultimately, Newman says, the discussion should be about using NYCHA land to create more low-income housing. The dilemma there is the same one that prompted the authority to conceive the land-lease scheme. Federal law prohibits construction of new public housing, and years of cuts in state and federal operating assistance has choked NYCHA’s budget. In July, after NYCHA began accepting applications online, its waiting list reached 227,000 people, more than its total number of apartments.

“It is important to remember that NYCHA’s mission and mandate are to serve low-income New Yorkers and not to maximize the market rents available to private real-estate developers,” she says. “There’s no funding. That’s the problem.”