The Tenant Legislative Platform for 2015

The Alliance for Tenant Power, coordinated by Tenants & Neighbors, and the Real Rent Reform Campaign, staffed by Met Council on Housing, have agreed upon a nine-bill platform for the 2015 legislative session.

The most important bill would repeal vacancy deregulation, so that landlords would no longer be able to remove apartments from rent and eviction protections when they become vacant if the legal rent can be raised to $2,500 or more. It would also reregulate all apartments that have been deregulated in the last 20 years, if the current rent is $5,000 or less.

Another bill would repeal the statutory vacancy bonus, the 1997 amendment that lets landlords automatically add 20 percent to the rent on vacant apartments.

A third would repeal the preferential rent loophole. Under this scam, landlords can charge tenants less than the legal rent (anything lower is called a preferential rent), but when the lease expires, the landlord can raise the rent based on the higher legal rent. This can produce increases of several hundred dollars per month.

Major Capital Improvement reform is another important bill. This one would make MCI rent increases for building-wide improvements temporary, and also would require them to be listed as separate surcharges on the rent bill. Thus they would not be compounded with the base rent, and the rent increase would end when the MCI is paid off.

The vacancy bonus, the preferential rent loophole, and MCI rent increases are the three major loopholes in current law that are helping landlords price tenants out of their regulated apartments. They must go.

 Fifth, we are supporting a bill that would extend rent-stabilization coverage to former Mitchell-Lama and project-based Section 8 developments, regardless of when they were constructed. Under current law, those constructed or occupied by December 31, 1973 come under stabilization, but later buildings do not.

A sixth bill would bring relief to rent-controlled tenants, who pay much higher increases than stabilized renters, even though their household incomes are on average considerably lower.

Another bill would tighten enforcement of Individual Apartment Improvements, the mechanism landlords use to jack up rents on vacant apartments beyond the deregulation threshold, by installing new kitchen and bathroom appliances or high-end cosmetics such as granite countertops. As these increases are based on how much they spend on renovations, landlords often claim they spent much more than they really did. Under current law, unless the tenant moving into an apartment files a challenge, there is no oversight.

An eighth bill would ban illegal fees, by prohibiting landlords from imposing surcharges for installation or use of a tenant-installed appliance where the tenant pays for electrical utility service.

Finally, we are supporting a bill to ban discrimination in renting based on source of income. This would make it illegal for a landlord to refuse to rent to a prospective tenant simply because she has a Section 8 voucher or other form of rental assistance. New York City has such a law, but this protection is needed statewide.

 

Raising the deregulation threshold again would be fraud

It is especially important that tenants convey to their legislators that we demand full repeal of vacancy destabilization, and that merely raising the threshold for deregulation again is unacceptable.

Without repealing vacancy deregulation, big landlords will spend whatever it takes to reach the threshold. Speculators will still have an incentive to pay too much for rent-stabilized buildings and then try to force tenants out. Dishonest landlords will continue illegal deregulations by failing to register with the state housing agency and watching the clock tick for four years; if the tenant fails to file an overcharge complaint by then, the landlord gets away with it. 

However, the Alliance for Tenant Power and the Real Rent Reform Campaign have agreed not to push for one of the tenant movement’s long-term goals this year: to repeal the Urstadt Law and thereby restore home rule powers to New York City. Urstadt unfairly prohibits the city from enacting stronger rent and eviction protections. But there is no way the Republican majority in the Senate will agree to repeal.

The real-estate lobby will oppose any real reform, and also hopes to win weakening amendments at the negotiating table. The landlords want to reverse the Roberts decision, the 2008 Court of Appeals ruling that held they could not deregulate apartments in buildings receiving J-51 tax benefits. They would also like to undo other decisions by the state’s highest court; industry representatives recently accused it of “anti-landlord bias.” 

On the assumption that we will not be able to win everything we need this year—which seems likely—the two coalitions have agreed to push for the shortest extender possible, two years, to 2017. The state legislature is seemingly incapable of dealing with rent laws except in a sunset year. This is why the landlords proposed an extraordinary 14-year extender last time, from 2011 to 2025. As long as they can keep the deregulation mechanisms in place, they are willing to keep renewing the laws, knowing that eventually there will be so few units left in the system that tenants will no longer have the political power to get them renewed.