The Atlantic Yards development in Brooklyn may not contain much of the promised 2,250 units of affordable housing, developer Bruce Ratner implied in a November interview. He told The Wall Street Journal that the state’s current incentives for developments where half the rental units are priced for middle- and low-income tenants “don’t work for a high-rise building that’s union built.”
He added that he planned to have the buildings constructed by assembling prefabricated modular units instead of by traditional construction, which would save money by reducing both the wages and hours for workers on the project. He said he had “accepted the fact that we’re not going to get more subsidy.”
Atlantic Yards Report, Norman Oder’s “watchdog blog,” termed that announcement a “bait and switch.” Ratner, he noted, had won support for the development from unions, advocacy organizations, and elected officials by promising that it would contain affordable housing and be built by union labor.
Though the state approved Forest City Ratner’s revised proposal in 2009, Oder said, a report by the Kahr Real Estate Group, commissioned by the Council of Brooklyn Neighborhoods, warned that “it is extremely unlikely that the full project can be financed and completed within 10 years at a profit by a private sector developer without substantial subsidies in excess of what has already been currently proposed.”
“That’s exactly what Ratner admitted,” Oder wrote, “and why he’s seeking concessions from unions and/or building modular.”
Brooklyn Speaks, a Web site sponsored by a coalition of community groups, speculated that Ratner might have been “posturing for a negotiation with union officials aimed at reducing wages for labor on his project” or preparing to claim an “Affordable Housing Subsidy Unavailability” under the developer’s agreement with the Empire State Development Corporation. “It’s also likely that the result will be not only a reduction to union scale, but fewer affordable units than promised, with a longer wait for those units to be delivered, and at a greater cost to the public,” the site said.