Court Approves Final Stuy-Town Settlement

A state appeals court has formally approved the settlement of a lawsuit challenging illegal overcharges at Peter Cooper Village/Stuyvesant Town—the suit that led to the 2009 Roberts v. Tishman Speyer decision.

In that decision, the state’s highest court ruled that Tishman Speyer, which bought the 11,000-apartment complex in 2006 for a record $5.4 billion, had illegally deregulated 4,311 apartments while receiving J-51 tax breaks for renovating rent-stabilized units. On April 10, the Appellate Term approved the settlement, which determines how tenants are repaid for those overcharges.

The deregulated apartments will be put back into rent stabilization until June 2020, when the complexes’ J-51 benefits expire. The settlement also includes a formula for resetting rents in those apartments, and tenants overcharged between 2003 and 2011 will receive compensation. Lawyers for the plaintiffs told the Daily News that about 27,500 tenants and former tenants would get checks ranging from $150 to more than $100,000. Tenants and Neighbors estimated that the settlement’s total value was $173 million in cash and rent reductions.

The case highlighted the “predatory equity” model of the ’00s housing bubble, in which real-estate investors bought property at prices that could be profitable only if they raised rents illegally and drove out rent-stabilized tenants through harassment. It is estimated that 80,000 to 200,000 apartments were illegally deregulated while the owner was receiving J-51 benefits.