A group of tenants of the Pinnacle Group, the “predatory equity” landlord that became notorious for trying to evict almost one-fourth of its 22,000 tenants, have asked a federal appeals court to overturn a settlement approved last year in their class-action suit against the landlord.
The objecting tenants appeared in the U.S. Court of Appeals in Manhattan April 22 to petition for a new settlement. Lawyers for them said that under the original settlement, more than three-fourths of the tenants charged illegally high rent would not be eligible for compensation.
“The monetary compensation to tenants is inadequate, and the settlement lacks any oversight,” says Kim Powell of Buyers and Renters United to Save Harlem, one of the tenants seeking a new settlement. “Many tenants felt that oversight was an extremely important piece in light of the fact that the Pinnacle Group had entered into numerous and similar settlement agreements with various governmental agencies, and each time failed to comply or repeated their questionable practices over and over.”
The lawsuit was initiated in 2007 by BRUSH and certified as a class action in 2010. It charged that Pinnacle’s practices toward its tenants were criminal enough to qualify as illegal under the federal Racketeering Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act.
“This settlement cannot be seen as a slap on the wrist,” says Powell. “Many of our community have been economically torn apart because of the predatory practices of investors like the Pinnacle Group.”