District  69 Eli Northrup

Will you publicize an endorsement from Met Council Action?  Yes             

Will you pledge to meet with us regularly?  Yes

What type of housing do you live in?  Regulated rental apartment

Are you now, or have you ever been a landlord?  No

If yes, how many units?

Does your campaign accept contributions from real estate developers (including related individuals), corporate lobbyists, organizations that participate in the carceral system, and/or landlords?  No

Have you ever worked in, or had another affiliation with, the Real Estate industry?  No

Have any of your campaign or advisory staff held a position as a corporate lobbyist or an executive role with the Real Estate industry? No

If so, how can we be assured you will have tenants’ interests in mind?  

Do you believe housing is a human right? Yes

If so, what does that mean to you?  If housing is a human right, we cannot treat it as a vehicle for the wealthy to get wealthier. Treating housing as a commodity is part of the reason that we have ended up with skyrocketing rents. It is also partially why it can be so difficult to build new and affordable housing. We must transition from a model that centers maximizing profit for developers and managers to one that puts people at its core.

In many cases, housing has moved beyond being a vehicle for working families to obtain security over time to a speculative game for real estate developers and the ultra-wealthy. Too often, our economy treats housing units more as financial instruments and commodities than as homes. At the extreme, we see investors buying up units in luxury buildings that then go unused, or used only a few days a year, artificially exacerbating our housing shortage. Putting people at the center of our housing policy does not mean jeopardizing housing as a driver of greater economic attainment for working families. Decommodification means working to eliminate incentives for real estate speculators to treat housing as simply another thing to be bought and sold at the expense of working families struggling to find safety and stability.

What actions have you taken in the past to fight for housing justice?  As a public defender, I see every day how housing instability can upend a person’s life, exacerbate mental health issues, and lead to job loss, substance abuse, and disruptions in education. Part of being a holistic public defender is working with a team of interdisciplinary advocates to address all of a client’s needs, which often means working directly with social workers and housing advocates to  find or protect safe and stable housing. I have directly represented clients in housing court who are facing eviction. For the past decade, I have worked with countless families facing housing insecurity, and I know just how hard it can be for people living paycheck to paycheck, without comprehensive childcare, or with mental health challenges.

As a policy advocate, I assisted in the Clean Slate NY campaign, which resulted in the passage of  a law that will automatically seal misdemeanors after three years and most felony convictions after eight years. Record sealing helps people access housing because it prevents landlords from inquiring about those sealed convictions. It also means when they run background checks, they will not see these convictions at all, making it much easier to attain housing for people with criminal legal system contact to attain housing than it was before.

I also represented Shamika Crawford in a case that led to the creation of a new hearing in criminal court cases—a “Crawford” hearing—that ensures that people are not rendered homeless as a matter of course simply because of an arrest. Prior to Crawford, judges routinely issued orders mere hours after a person’s arrest that resulted in the de facto summary eviction of thousands of people in New York City every year without a modicum of due process. Not only would these orders prevent people who had not been found guilty of anything from returning to their homes, but they often had the effect of separating families. This is what happened to Ms. Crawford when an order of protection was perfunctorily issued by the court, barring her from seeing her children and locking her out of her home despite being the lessee. Working with Ms. Crawford and my co-counsel, I successfully argued that a hearing was required before a court order could be issued that would deprive someone of their basic rights. This helps prevent people from being summarily kicked out of their homes without even a hearing. These hearings require the prosecution to show not only why the order of protection is needed, but why the deprivation of housing is justified. Our efforts were covered in the New York Times in an article with the headline “A Judge’s Order Left Her Homeless. A New Ruling Will Help Others Like Her.”: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/25/nyregion/order-of-protection-domestic-violence.html

What are the most pressing housing issues, and what would you do as an elected official to address them?   The first priority of any affordable housing plan is keeping people in their homes. Families should not have to worry about losing their home because of unreasonable rent hikes, discrimination, or retaliation. That is why I will fight for Good Cause Eviction, strong rent stabilization laws, the Housing Access Voucher Program, and the Tenant Opportunity to Purchase Act.

I’ll also champion a statewide right to counsel in eviction proceedings, strengthening protections against unjust evictions by ensuring that everyone has not only a right to a lawyer in eviction proceedings, but adequate time to defend themselves.This will protect New Yorkers and keep them in their homes as we work to develop stronger rent regulations, more comprehensive housing first programs, and more housing.

We also must build more affordable housing without giving developers a blank check.There is a profound lack of affordable and deeply affordable housing across the state, leading to an eviction crisis. We have seen construction of apartment buildings that are little more than vehicles for the ultra-wealthy to stash money. We have seen developments that divide neighborhoods, strangle small and local businesses, warehouse rent-regulated units, and exacerbate racial segregation. And we have seen building that pushes out current residents and squeezes working families. Landlords of rent stabilized apartments also work to take apartments out of stabilization through the use of MCIs, IAIs, and warehousing. This artificially decreases the available housing stock through simply taking housing off the market or raising rents beyond what families can afford. The state must make more housing available so that regular New Yorkers can afford to stay in their homes, and as a legislator I would support building social housing and affordable housing, ending warehousing, reforming SEQRA to allow construction of housing without preventing communities of color from fighting environmental racism. As an elected I will work to get more housing that is affordable and deeply affordable constructed by supporting actions like the creation of the Social Housing Development Authority.

Encouraging the development of more affordable housing, however, does not mean giving real estate developers a blank check or ignoring community input. The 421a tax exemption for real estate developers is not the answer. We need affordable housing incentives that are responsive to community concerns and hold developers accountable for creating homes that are actually affordable for working families. We must also ensure that our affordable housing development projects include strong labor standards and help to create good paying jobs so working families can afford to live and thrive here.

Have you or anyone close to you (family, friend, etc) been evicted or been threatened with eviction?  Yes

Have you ever had to fight a landlord for repairs or faced harassment?  Yes

Do you believe that housing should be decommodified? Yes

Please explain your answer. If housing is a human right, we cannot treat it as a vehicle for the wealthy to get wealthier. Treating housing as a commodity is part of the reason that we have ended up with skyrocketing rents. It is also partially why it can be so difficult to build new and affordable housing. We must transition from a model that centers maximizing profit for developers and managers to one that puts people at its core.

In many cases, housing has moved beyond being a vehicle for working families to obtain security over time to a speculative game for real estate developers and the ultra-wealthy. Too often, our economy treats housing units more as financial instruments and commodities than as homes. At the extreme, we see investors buying up units in luxury buildings that then go unused, or used only a few days a year, artificially exacerbating our housing shortage. Putting people at the center of our housing policy does not mean jeopardizing housing as a driver of greater economic attainment for working families. Decommodification means working to eliminate incentives for real estate speculators to treat housing as simply another thing to be bought and sold at the expense of working families struggling to find safety and stability.

Do you believe in publicly owned and controlled housing?  Yes

What is one rent and/or eviction protection you would enact if you had the opportunity?  The most important thing we could do right now is strengthen our eviction protections with a more robust legal defense system. To that end, I would enact Good Cause paired with a statewide right to counsel in eviction proceedings to protect people from un

Do you agree that all evictions are bad?  Yes

Why or why not?  As a general matter all evictions represent a collective policy failure. Even in the rare instances where the eviction is based on grave concerns such as the safety of others, they represent a failure of all other potential resolutions and systems.This is particularly true when people are evicted for nonpayment or because of criminal legal system contact that is itself related to economic precarity. It may also be the utter failure or lack of dispute resolution resources and supports. No matter the specific cause of the eviction, the eviction itself represents a failure, not victory, of governmental policy.

Evictions are, likewise, inherently violent acts. To deprive someone of their home is, in many ways, to deprive them of the daily  stability on which so much relies. It is to consign them to the whims of chance and the randomness of charity. Forced removal from the home creates homelessness, decreases job prospects, exacerbates health issues, and can result in a disconnection from community.

We need stronger eviction protections and pathways to ownership so that evictions don’t occur. We cannot simply punish people by taking away their housing when they are struggling. All that succeeds in doing is making their struggle worse. If housing is a human right, as it surely must be, then we have no right to alienate people from their housing on such flimsy bases.

Do you support the concept of universal rent control?  Yes

Do you support the NYCHA 2.0 Rental Assistance Demonstration (RAD) and other privatization schemes?  No

Please explain why or why not Privatization is not the answer to NYCHA. While RAD was created with what I believe to be the best intentions to solve chronic underfunding of public housing across the country, it has generally been a raw deal for NYCHA residents. Privatization exposes residents to private, profit-seeking landlords and broader market forces. RAD programs in particular have led to increased evictions at NYCHA housing. It also has meant that tenants have had even greater difficulty when it comes to getting basic maintenance done—private managers have given tenants the runaround sending them to the Authority when the manager is now the one in charge of fielding requests and repairs in buildings they manage. Privatization also pulls public housing outside of oversight from the federal monitor and from NYCHA itself. While NYCHA desperately needs funding, I don’t believe programs like RAD provide the answer. If that funding doesn’t actually transform tenants’ lives for the better, then it has no point.

What do you see as the best strategies to rectify these problems?  We must support NYCHA so that it can realize long-term growth. This will first require ensuring the state is providing sufficient funding to NYCHA. This means finding ways to raise money for public housing. We can begin to address this by implementing a more progressive income tax, a tax on wealth, and a capital gains tax would raise several billions of dollars per year for the state. We must also think about not just doing repairs, but doing them in a manner that benefits tenants now and in the long-term. We should be doing retrofits and renovations that lead to lower energy use and provide greater durability. This will keep bill costs lower in the long run and reduce the need for repairs. For example, replacing the current toilets in NYCHA apartments with low flow toilets can substantially shrink the likelihood of toilet-based leaks and flooding, thereby lowering total repairs that must be done in units across NYCHA.

NYCHA also needs more capacity to address tenant needs. This means hiring more people to be responsive to tenants. Given the abject decay of units and sometimes whole complexes, NYCHA needs new staff to be able to begin rebuilding trust with tenants. This staff needs to be prepared to do repairs, give accurate estimates of when issues will be resolved, and be accountable to tenants.

How would you use your office to put pressure on landlords to make repairs and stop harassing tenants?  I will make sure that housing is a key part of what I work on as an Assemblymember. To that end, I will have a staff member dedicated to working on NYCHA issues. I want to make sure that I always know what’s going on in the public housing in my district and that I can move quickly to address issues there. At the same time, I will work for every renter in my district to ensure they are not being harassed by their landlords. Preventing landlord harassment requires both external and internal pressure on the landlord. That means helping my constituents be tenants that are well versed in how to fight landlords to create internal pressure, and having my office reprimand and press the landlord externally.

I will connect constituents to services, such as lawyers, when it makes sense to bring attorneys into the equation. I’ll do that by leveraging my years of public defense work and working with civil legal service providers across the city and state. In addition to civil legal services, I will work to ensure constituents know when to reach out to agencies such as the NYC Commission on Human Rights. I will also provide know-your-rights trainings so that tenants know their rights when it comes to dealing with landlords.

When it comes to external pressure, I will intercede early and often. I will write  letters to remind landlords of their legal obligations to their tenants. I will go to landlords directly and demand the cessation of tenant harassment and neglect. As I learn about which landlords are habitual abusers, I will name and shame them publicly.

Do you support regulating the 300,000 deregulated rent-stabilized apartments? Yes

Will you support increased funding and oversight hearings of DHCR’s Office of Rent Administration to ensure timely responses on overcharge complaints and rent reduction orders for hazardous conditions?  Yes

Do you support stronger penalties against landlords that practice source of income discrimination? Yes

Do you support Good Cause Eviction Protections?  Yes

What will you do to ensure Good Cause gets passed this session?  First I would educate people about the bill. This can be done in town halls where I invite the bill’s sponsors (AM Hunter and Sen. Salazar) and housing experts to speak about Good Cause. It can also be through writing op-eds and giving floor speeches. I will loudly champion Good Cause, providing facts that support its passage. I will work to educate my colleagues, drawing on my career as a public defender, where I saw everyday how a lack of housing can destabilize entire families and communities.

Additionally, given the fact that Good Cause will save municipalities and the state money by lowering the number of evictions and likely lowering the number of housing vouchers needed for newly homeless people due to evictions, I will advocate to leadership to include Good Cause in the budget, which could insulate it from bad faith attacks. Finally, I will work with advocates and the bill sponsors to shepherd the bill through the chambers, assisting in convincing my colleagues on the fence, as well as leadership, that this is a truly vital bill and that landlords and the real estate lobby are wrong about it. I will work to get Good Cause on the floor for a vote.

Will you support ending MCIs?  Yes

Will you commit to fully funding the Housing Access Voucher Program?  Yes

Do you support the Tenant Opportunity to Purchase Act (TOPA)?  Yes

How will you support tenants in your district opting into TOPA?  Supporting tenants who want to take advantage of TOPA means helping them organize and access resources. In buildings where there is no tenants union but there is a desire to purchase, I will help those tenants organize. I will also do my best to connect those tenants to other tenants’ unions so that they can strategize together, or possibly start a neighborhood union. I will also connect these tenants unions to nonprofits who may be able to help them purchase their buildings.

Do you support the move to legalize basement apartments and Accessory dwelling units?  Yes

Do you support 421a or Gov Hochul’s proposed 485w?  No

Do you support fully funding the Unemployment Bridge Program (S3192 | A4821)?  Yes

Do you support the vacancy reset bill?  No

Are you committed to making sure every tenant in the state has free access to counsel in Housing Court by fully funding Right to Counsel in 2025’s budget?  Yes

What will you do to ensure that OCA makes proceedings for tenants facing eviction fair by slowing down cases to match the capacity of legal service providers?  Yes

Do you support the creation of a Social Housing Development Authority?  Yes

Do you support legislation to reform the NYC Rent Guidelines Board?  Yes

Do you support the Universal Rent Control bill (to be introduced) – do you support expanding rent regulation to smaller buildings?  Yes

Do you support increasing the Individual Apartment Increases (IAI) allowance?  No