Goodbye, Committee to Save New York!

Before he was even elected governor of New York State in 2010, Andrew Cuomo met with executives of real-estate and big-business groups to ask them to create an advocacy organization that could counter the power of labor unions and progressive groups in Albany.

The result was the Committee to Save New York, which became the top-spending lobbying group in Albany in 2011 and 2012. The $17 million it raised from developers and Wall Street types paid for extensive television and radio advertising in 2011 and 2012 supporting Cuomo’s moves to reduce government spending on education and health care, cut taxes on the rich, and slash salaries and benefits for government workers.

Dubbed “the Committee to Starve New York” or “the Committee to Save 1 Percent New York” by progressive critics, this outfit helped Cuomo achieve those goals. The major impetus for forming CSNY came from three organizations: the Real Estate Board of New York, the Partnership for New York City (which should be called the “Partnership for New York City Corporate Interests”), and the Business Council of New York State.

Under rules adopted by Cuomo’s New York State Joint Commission on Public Ethics, CSNY initially did not have to disclose who gave it money. Once new rules requiring such disclosure took effect last year, it became inactive. But there was another reason CSNY went silent: It accepted $2 million from casino-gambling interests shortly before Cuomo came out in favor of a state constitutional amendment legalizing Las Vegas-style casinos in upstate New York.

This was too embarrassing even for Cuomo, who switched horses: He began raising funds through the state Democratic Party, which he controls, for advertising to support his agenda. The governor has now created a new advocacy group, “NY Jobs Now,” to support Referendum #1, which will appear on the Nov. 5 statewide ballot. If passed, it will allow the construction of four casinos in the Catskills, the Albany area, and the Southern Tier. 

So after three years, Cuomo’s original creation went out of business. At the end of August, CSNY mouthpiece Michael McKeon announced that the group was folding its tent. “We came together to challenge the special interests in Albany and neutralize them and we believe we were successful,” he declared. Special interests, indeed! McKeon said that paperwork to disband the committee had been filed and unspent funds returned to their donors.

McKeon was an operative for former Governor George Pataki. Now a partner in Mercury Public Affairs, the go-to consulting group for large corporate interests, he was also the head of “Republicans for Cuomo” in 2010. He is now the spokesperson for “New Yorkers for Proven Leadership,” a “super PAC” formed to promote the mayoral candidacy of Republican Joseph Lhota.

In February 2011, Community Voices Heard and VOCAL-NY sent a letter to the state Commission on Public Integrity, which was then responsible for enforcing the lobbying laws, complaining that CSNY had failed to register as a lobbyist as required. The commission (which a few months later was replaced by the Joint Commission on Public Integrity) acknowledged receiving the complaint, but never acted on it.

The CSNY represented the latest incarnation of what the late journalists Jack Newfield and Paul Du Brul called “the permanent government,” in the title of their landmark 1981 book. In it, they documented how an elite group of unelected power brokers—real-estate developers among them—controlled the political and economic power of New York City, regardless of who was in office. The names and faces in that “permanent government” have changed since then, but their desire to prevent democracy from interfering with their interests hasn’t.