State AG Investigating Airbnb

Seeking to find out if a short-term rental service for travelers is creating massive violations of rent laws, New York State Attorney General Eric Schneiderman on Oct. 7 issued a subpoena to Airbnb Inc. for information on the 15,000 people who rent out space in their homes through its Web site.

A 2010 state law intended to curb the illegal use of apartments as transient hotels generally prohibits people from subletting their apartments for less than 30 days. A “person familiar with the probe” told Crain’s that Schneiderman’s office is looking at whether property managers or brokers are renting out large numbers of units through Airbnb, or if individuals are renting their apartments to transients for a significant percentage of the year.

An Airbnb official posted a blog saying the company will fight the probe, calling it “unreasonably broad.” In an Oct. 3 post, cofounder Brian Chesky contended that “our hosts are not hotels” but part of a “new movement called the sharing economy.”

“They are illegally turning their homes into commercial enterprises,” responded State Senator Liz Krueger (D-Manhattan), sponsor of the 2010 law, who noted that many are in rent-stabilized or tax-subsidized buildings. “Every apartment turned into an illegal hotel unit with the assistance of Airbnb is another home unavailable to everyday New Yorkers.” Residents also have the “right not to be frightened by groups of strangers having keys to their buildings,” she added.

A crucial criterion is whether residents are present in the apartment while the travelers they rent space to are staying there. Last month, the city Environmental Control Board overturned a $2,400 fine levied against an East Village landlord after a tenant rented out a room in his apartment through Airbnb while he was out of town. The board held that the rental did not violate the law banning short-term sublets, because the man’s roommate—a “permanent occupant” of the apartment—was still present.