New York City’s Department of Housing Preservation & Development and the state Department of Financial Services have taken steps towards improving conditions in multifamily buildings.
In a letter addressed to banks, DFS Superintendent Benjamin Lawsky proposed new guidelines for complying with the federal Community Reinvestment Act. The CRA was signed into law by President Jimmy Carter in 1977 after national pressure from housing advocates to curb “redlining,” discriminatory lending practices against low-income neighborhoods. However, some critics say banks have abused the CRA by brokering predatory loans in low-income communities, and there is no federal penalty for not complying with the law.
Superintendent Lawsky proposed new guidelines that could make bank loans ineligible to help the bank’s rating under the CRA if they lead to a reduction in the number of affordable units, convert affordable units to market-rate rents, have “been written in an unsound manner,” or lead to substandard living conditions (as determined by municipal agencies such HPD). However, there is still no penalty for making such loans.
Meanwhile, HPD has adopted a rule that allows issuing an order to require a building owner to repair underlying conditions that cause class B and C violations, such as mold and water leaks. (Class C violations are considered “immediately hazardous.”) Instead of merely fixing burst pipes or painting over mold, the landlord would be given four months to fix the conditions that cause mold or water leaks.
But HPD only expects to issue about 50 such orders citywide, and they will only go to buildings that have widespread B and C violations. For buildings with 3-5 units, half must have such a violation. For buildings with 6-9 units, 25 percent must, and for buildings with 10 or more units, 15 percent must. The rule exempts buildings with one or two units, those that have already received other enforcement orders from HPD, and those that have received preservation loans from HPD or the Housing Development Corporation. There are also exemptions for buildings that have new owners and were recently foreclosed.
These new proposals and rules are a step towards improving housing conditions. However, the HPD rule has a limited scope, and the DFS proposals are not final.