Jobs for New York PAC was formed in May by leaders of the Real Estate Board of New York. All of the almost $7 million it raised came from real estate. Its donor list reads like a Who’s Who of REBNY leadership: Dursts, Tishmans, Silversteins, the ubiquitous Leonard Litwin. (As real-estate companies generally set up limited liability corporations for separate properties they own, they can exploit a loophole in state campaign-finance law, which lets individual LLCs contribute the maximum amount allowed even if they’re owned by the same entity.)
None of the PAC’s money came from the three unions who accepted REBNY’s invitation to join: the Mason Tenders’ District Council of Greater New York, United Food and Commercial Workers Local 1500, and the New York City District Council of Carpenters. These unions apparently hoped that electing development-friendly Council members would mean more construction jobs.
As of Sept. 6, Jobs for New York had spent $4,879,000 on 22 City Council races. (The next campaign finance filings are due Sept. 20, so these numbers will certainly rise.) The money went largely to polling and direct mail, but it also hired door-to-door canvassers in some races.
Most of the flyers Jobs for New York mailed were misleadingly liberal, talking about how the candidates will fight for more affordable housing and never mentioning REBNY or its role in trying to eliminate rent and eviction protection laws. It also sent out attack mailers, saying that “Brooklyn can’t trust” Ede Fox and Olanike Alabi, and insinuating that the Texas-born Carlos Menchaca was a carpetbagger.
Groups undertaking this kind of independent expenditure cannot coordinate with the candidates they support, but they can spend a lot more money. Candidates receiving matching public funds weren’t allowed to spend more than $168,000 in the primary, and Jobs for New York far exceeded that in most of the races it targeted. (Inez Dickens was the only candidate it endorsed who opted out of public financing.)
Most of the REBNY-backed candidates who won were already strongly favored. In competitive races, they won one, Laurie Cumbo in Fort Greene. Paul Vallone and Kirsten John Foy might add to that if they win after recounts. But REBNY lost three big races where the PAC spent a combined total of $997,000: backing Sara Gonzalez, Manuel Caughman against Daneek Miller in Queens, and Ari Kagan, who lost to Chaim Deutsch in Brooklyn’s District 48 (Brighton Beach-Sheepshead Bay). Kagan, who trails by about 300 votes, has asked for a recount.
Three REBNY-backed winners, Cumbo, Mark Levine, and Alan Maisel of Brooklyn’s District 46 (Marine Park-Canarsie), issued statements condemning its independent expenditures. “I want to apologize to all those who have been the subject of and who have been subjected to these mailings,” said Maisel, who will replace term-limited Lew Fidler. Jobs for New York spent $284,000 on the campaign. Cumbo told the New York World, “I don’t owe REBNY anything.”
The City Council has little power over rent laws because state law denies the city home rule. But it has enormous power over development and zoning. Under the Bloomberg administration and Speaker Christine Quinn, developers have held the upper hand. REBNY’s motives in setting up this front are clear: They fear a new mayor who will be less inclined to go along with their schemes, and they hoped to elect Councilmembers who will roll over for them.
Will some of these Councilmembers who have benefitted from this independent expenditure support inappropriate or damaging development projects or zoning changes? The candidates who were helped by REBNY need to be watched carefully.