vanessafornyc.com
not active
https://www.instagram.com/VanessaTAronson/
What type of housing do you live in? Own co-op, condo, or private home
Are you now, or have you ever been a landlord? No
If yes, how many units and briefly describe what your experience has been.
Does your campaign accept contributions from real estate developers (including related individuals), corporate lobbyists, organizations that participate in the carceral system, and/or landlords? No
Have you ever worked in, or had another affiliation with, the Real Estate industry? No
Have any of your campaign or advisory staff held a position as a corporate lobbyist or an executive role with the Real Estate industry? No
If so, how can we be assured you will have tenants’ interests in mind?
Do you believe housing is a human right? Yes
If so, what does that mean to you, and if not, why not? I’ve volunteered in my community to help physically count the number of individuals experiencing street homelessness. We live in one of the wealthiest places in the world, yet see people experiencing both routine housing insecurity and street homelessness. When I say that housing is a human right, I mean that absolutely no one should face homelessness.
What actions have you taken in the past to fight for housing justice? I previously volunteered and collaborated with Picture the Homeless and centered advocacy for Housing First policies in my 2017 City Council race and politics since then.
What are the most pressing housing issues, and what would you do as an elected official to address them? I know first-hand what it is like trying to live in New York City on a first-year teacher’s salary. Also, because of my experience working as a classroom teacher in a community outside of District 4 (I worked at MS319 in Washington Heights and as an ATR), I have a wider lens than my competitors about key issues impacting New York City and just how acutely lack of affordability is impacting families in New York City, including a number of my students whose families experienced homelessness during the time I was their teacher. These experiences inform my policy perspectives and priorities.
We are in the midst of an affordability and housing crisis. As a member of Community Board 8, I sat on the Land Use and Zoning Committees. I experienced first hand the important and grueling ULURP process and know what it is like to critically examine housing proposals.
We must protect the current stock of affordable housing, hold the Department of Housing Preservation and Development accountable to deliver the affordable units that our community needs, convert commercial to residential wherever possible, and build modern middle class housing by working with non-profit and other developers who prioritize affordable housing.
Have you or anyone close to you (family, friend, etc) been evicted or been threatened with eviction? Yes
Have you ever had to fight a landlord for repairs or faced harassment? Yes
Do you believe that housing should be decommodified (publicly owned and tenant-controlled)?
Yes
Please explain your answer. While I don’t oppose the notion of private ownership, we should decommodify housing and return that housing to public ownership with tenant control whenever possible.
What is one rent and/or eviction protection you would enact if you had the opportunity?
I support City Council Intro 623, which would raise civil penalties for unlawful eviction, withhold tax subsidies, abatements and exemptions from building owners who engage in unlawful evictions, and allow owners who engage in unlawful evictions to cure their record by providing affordable housing.
Do you agree that all evictions are violent? Yes
Why or why not? The act of forcibly removing someone from their home is innately violent. Evictions have devastating consequences that only exacerbate the affordability, homelessness, and unemployment crises. City Council has an obligation to develop and steward holistic programs to avoid and mitigate eviction as a solution to protecting affordable housing.
Do you support the concept of universal rent control? Yes
For decades the Rent Guidelines Board has fueled the affordability crisis it was created to address. Most NYC tenants are rent-burdened, and hundreds of thousands of families, primarily Black and brown, are forced to deprive themselves of necessities to keep a roof over their heads, while owners’ profits hover near the 40% mark. Do you support freezing or even rolling back rents given these circumstances?
Yes
Do you support proposals to revise the RGB to make it more responsive to the needs of the tenants it was created to protect? Yes
Why or why not? NYC is in the midst of an affordability crisis. Pricing tenants out of their homes will only exacerbate the problem. RGB must be held accountable to effectively utilize the research it conducts on operating and maintenance costs, financing, housing supply, and cost of living indices, and ultimately offer productive methods of keeping affordable housing affordable.
Do you support the NYCHA 2.0 Rental Assistance Demonstration (RAD) and other privatization schemes? No
Please explain why or why not: Privatization reliably leads to net losses for tenants as oversight decreases and housing becomes more dependent on unaccountable actors.
NYCHA has suffered from chronic underfunding, neglect, and disrepair. What do you see as the best strategies to rectify these problems?
The only possible solution is to increase funding. We cannot address issues of neglect and disrepair with austerity budgets that exacerbate the problem.
How would you use your office to put pressure on landlords to make repairs and stop harassing tenants?
My office will prioritize constituent services and ensure our staff is on the case when we receive reports of apartments in disrepair or tenant harassment. We’ll also advertise these services regularly so tenants are aware of the resources.
Do you support regulating the 300,000 deregulated rent-stabilized apartments? Yes
Do you support significant expansion of HPD’s emergency repair program, including adequate funding, with the city correcting hazardous violations when the landlord doesn’t act promptly, then bills the landlord for the repairs and takes title to the building if the landlord doesn’t pay, keeping it as social housing? Yes
Why or why not? Being a landlord is conditional on legal adherence, it is not a right. Landlords who violate the rights of their tenants are not entitled to retain building titles while disregarding our building laws.
Do you support stronger penalties against landlords that practice source of income discrimination? Yes
Despite the city’s commitment to a right to counsel for low income families facing eviction in housing court, currently fewer than half of eligible tenants are getting lawyers. Meanwhile, landlords have pressed the courts to speed up the eviction process so they can take advantage of record high rents, negating efforts to reduce homelessness. Do you support fully funded right to counsel and slowing down the housing court eviction mill?
Yes
What other ideas do you have to address the housing crisis, and what is your strategy for accomplishing them?
There are five core strategies I will prioritize on the Council.
1. Protect current stock of affordable housing
Reports show that NYC affordable housing saw a net loss of over 150,000 units, over 75% since 2019. In 2023 alone, there was an estimated net loss of over 4,000 rent-stabilized units. Units are being deregulated, often illegally. We must protect the affordable housing stock we have. We cannot accept a decline in the percentage of affordable units as street homelessness increases. Affordable housing is key to creating a just and safe city.
2. Hold HPD and DOB accountable for enforcing affordable housing requirements.
Agreements to develop new affordable housing units are great, but they’re worthless if they aren’t enforced. We’ve seen numerous instances where development with permitted FAR increases under Mandatory Inclusionary Housing didn’t follow through and complete the promised affordable housing, especially when affordable housing was permitted to be off-site. Oversight is essential to tackling the housing challenge and the only way we can ensure that the new Universal Affordability Preference program will succeed.
3. Convert commercial to residential, wherever possible
The current office vacancy rate in Midtown is 20 percent. Many of these empty spaces must be repurposed as residential housing as we seek to optimize our current spaces alongside the creation of new housing. We can build up to 85,000 new mixed-income units in Midtown Manhattan by increasing allowable density on sites where residential towers are already permitted.
4. Prioritize age in place housing for seniors
We need to ensure that seniors have access to rental assistance programs as well as accessibility upgrades and in-home care. We must ensure that they are protected against harassment and know their rights under the right to counsel law. We must build vibrant communities where seniors can age-in-place in the neighborhoods they built and sustained.
5. Build modern middle class housing
City of Yes is a start to the larger project of ensuring the middle-class can thrive in our city. But City of Yes, on its own, is only estimated to result in about 5,000 new units per year across the whole city. That’s not going to be enough, especially in District 4 where we’ve seen plenty of development, but not enough new housing to show for it. We must be vigilant in ensuring new construction meets affordability targets. For example, what we have seen, including right across the street from my apartment, are tenements with affordable housing being torn down so that towers with a relatively small number of enormous apartments can be built, meaning that even when developers participate in mandatory inclusionary housing and comply with their legal obligations, we end up with fewer affordable units than we had before. This isn’t acceptable, and it isn’t going to help solve the crisis.