Less than a month after they sued their landlord for refusing to stop charging them illegally high rents, 47 tenants at 2300 Fifth Ave. in Harlem received rent-refund checks totaling more than $250,000.
The 2300 Fifth Avenue Tenants Association began seeking a rent reduction in October 2009, when the residents, mostly low- and moderate-income Afro-Americans, were frustrated by rising rents and their landlord’s failure to maintain the building while trying to push them out. More than 80 tenants signed on to the application filed with the state Division of Housing and Community Renewal, which was based upon a building-wide decrease in services. The 247-unit building is one of seven in a development that stretches from 139th to 142nd streets between Fifth Avenue and Malcolm X Boulevard. Many tenants still refer to it as Delano Village, but the new owners have renamed it Savoy Park.
The landlord then was Vantage Properties, notorious for its “predatory equity” business model that relied on aggressive tactics to drive tenants out and deregulate their apartments. In 2010, then state Attorney General Andrew Cuomo sued Vantage, alleging it had harassed hundreds of tenants by refusing to cash legitimate rent payments and illegally trying to evict them by charging that their apartments weren’t their primary residences, based on little to no evidence. Cuomo reached a $1 million settlement with Vantage, which agreed to reform its practices, but did not admit to any wrongdoing.
In October 2011, the DHCR issued a rent-reduction order, on the grounds that conditions including a broken security gate and a sealed trash compactor had decreased the services provided to tenants. The order rolled rents back to what they had been in the lease that was in effect before the one that was in effect in October 2009. It also froze rents until the services were restored. Vantage ignored the order, and tenants continued to pay the rent it had been charging, plus increases when they renewed their leases.
In 2012, Vantage sold the building to Savoy I LLC, an affiliate of real-estate fund Savannah. Savoy too ignored the DHCR order and continued to charge rents that hadn’t been reduced. When it sued a number of tenants in Housing Court for nonpayment, it included those illegally high rents in what it claimed they owed, and some were evicted.
The Tenants Association repeatedly brought these violations of the order to the landlord’s attention, to no avail. In June 2014, thanks to the efforts of tenant Annie Adams and Tenants Association President Charles Robinson, it retained the law firm of Himmelstein, McConnell, Gribben, Donoghue and Joseph. In August, the firm filed an action in state Supreme Court on behalf of 47 of the tenants listed on the rent-reduction order, seeking approximately $700,000, refunds for the rent overcharges they paid plus treble damages. Savoy responded by sending the 47 tenants rent-refund checks that amounted to over $250,000.
A number of issues remain to be resolved. Other tenants in the building who did not sign on as plaintiffs have not yet received rent refunds, although they are legally entitled to them. The refunds Savoy paid did not include treble damages, although that is part of the usual penalty when overcharges are presumed to be willful. A landlord immediately refunding rent overcharges is one factor the court may consider in determining whether it should award tenants treble damages.
In addition, Savoy argues that it did not know about the rent-reduction order until the tenants’ action was filed in August, which is another possible defense against treble damages. That claim is a bald-faced lie. Savoy filed an application in December 2013 to end the reductions and restore the rents, so it must have known about the order at that time, at the very latest. The Tenants Association is pushing to have Savoy replace its current management, which tried to get away with the overcharges.
Regardless of how the treble-damages issue is resolved, at a time of spiraling rents and increasingly aggressive efforts by landlords to decimate rent stabilization, the tenants won a tremendous victory.
David Hershey-Webb was the lawyer who represented the 2300 Fifth Ave. tenants.